XXXMAS Day Three - Group Sex
#3 of XXXMAS
Summary: Misty's always been envious of her polyamorous girlfriend's free spirit, so, when she's invited on a fourway date with another couple, she jumps at the chance for a bit of adventure. And maybe by the end of the night she ends up with more than just an interesting story to tell.
So, what is XXXMAS? For every day of the month of December I will post a short story, each featuring a different kink that was randomly chosen by several kink generators I found online. I'm doing this as a sort of writing challenge, test my skills with the help of some very different kinks and themes, as well as to build up a sort of writing portfolio. Each story is completely unrelated so you can skip whichever ones aren't your cup of tea.
I've never written erotica with this many people involved. It was definitely an interesting exercise and I'd like to write more foursomes and moresomes. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have to finish getting my stuff ready for this picnic my LGBT support group is holding tomorrow. I hope they like apple fritters.
Misty took a deep breath as the mantra You can do this repeated over and over in her head. She had no idea why she was so worried. Olive did this all the time! But, then again, Olive was different. She was confident and outgoing, the type of fun loving person everyone wanted to know. Her being an absolutely drop dead gorgeous Siamese with breath taking blue eyes, a slender waist, and D cup breasts that any man, woman, or enby, would die for helped too. Why the hell she wanted to date a frumpy plain grey cat like Misty with those darn love handles that just wouldn't quit was beyond her.
Another thing to note about Olive was her free spirit. She made it very clear to Misty on their first date that she didn't do monogamy. Much to Misty's own surprise, she found she was oddly okay with this and in their year together, Olive had had a number of casual flings, although nothing serious. She would always tell Misty about her dates the next day, often going into great deal over exactly what they'd done and she didn't exactly focus on how dinner and the movie went.
Misty's cheeks would always grow scarlet at her stories but she couldn't bring herself to turn away. She wished she had the courage that Olive had to do what she did. The idea of being with multiple people was an exciting one but also terrifying. What if she met someone and it turned out Olive wasn't as okay with her girlfriend seeing other people as she claimed to be? Nothing about the other feline even hinted at this but Misty couldn't help the stupid paranoia that creeped into her mind.
Then, one day, Olive had asked, "Why don't you come with?"
Misty had almost choked on her morning cereal. Olive had been talking about a pair of swingers she'd met at a club, a friendly dog couple who were also trans women like them, who had invited her over for dinner to have a little fun. Olive had never asked her to join her on one of her dates before and the shock of the question was clearly written all over Misty's face as her girlfriend's response was to giggle and say, "Come on, I see how into it you get when I tell you about my night outs." Misty's face had turned fifteen shades of red. Was she really that transparent? Being able to read her like a book, Olive had given her girlfriend a gentle smile as she said, "It's okay if you don't want to. Just know that if you do come with me and feel uncomfortable any time that it's okay to leave. Just say the word and we're outta there."
Olive had then shot her the biggest smile and how could she say no to that beautiful face? And, so, that was how a few days later the two found themselves parked outside of a quint little, one story blue house with a mailbox covered in brightly coloured painted flowers and more than one gnome on the lawn. It all seemed very normal. Hard to believe they were most likely going to fuck the two women that lived there.
"Ready to go in, babe?" Olive asked with her trademark toothy grin.
"Y-yeah, totally," Misty answered with a voice that cracked and a smile a little on the wonky side. If she held onto the steering wheel any tighter it would snap.
Olive's bright grin turned into more of a gentle smile as she placed a hand on her shoulder and, with a light squeeze, said, "It's okay, babe. I'll be there with you the whole time. Besides, Charlie and Tina are great. I've been WhatsApping them all week since I met them and they're just the best. I think you'll love Tina especially. You two have so much in common. I know you'll be insta-besties."
"Really?"
"Totally. But don't take my word for it. Let's get in there and start schmoozing!"
The two stepped out of the car and made their way up the path, Olive keeping an arm around her partner's shoulder the entire time, much to Misty's relief. When they arrived at the front door and Olive knocked, Misty couldn't help but hold her breath.
The door almost immediately swung open and the two were greeted by a red cocker spaniel who squealed like a dolphin on helium before pulling Olive into a massive hug. The two giggled like old school friends who hadn't seen each other in years as Olive returned the embrace. Meanwhile, Misty just stood there awkwardly smiling before the two women finally broke away and, with Olive giving her shoulder a friendly pat, pointed to Misty and said, "And, Tina, this is my number one girl, Misty."
Misty reached out her hand for a shake but it seemed the spaniel had other ideas as she wrapped her up in a near backbreaking hug. "It's so good to meet you!" she said in a voice only slightly lower pitched than before but still high enough to make Misty wonder if she'd ingested a squeaky toy recently. "I'm so happy to finally meet you, Misty. Olive talks about you, like, all the time. Come in, come in, dinner's almost ready and I want you to meet Charlie. She's in the living room." Tina then let go of the dazed feline and bounced back into the house. Olive's only response was to giggle at the whole encounter before walking inside, Misty making sure to follow her closely behind.
While Tina made her way into the kitchen to finish making dinner, the two cats walked into the living room to find a large Rottweiler on the couch drinking a beer. Even sitting, Misty could tell she would be a hulking giant when she stood. The dog wore a red sleeveless shirt that did nothing to hide the bulging muscles of her arms or the fact she wasn't wearing a bra. She also had on a very tight fitting pair of blue boxer-briefs, the outline of her large shaft clearly visible through them. Misty abd her reddened face had no idea where to look, in the end decide the floor was the safest option.
"Hey," the Rottweiler said in greeting with a raise of her beer. "Name's Charlotte but everyone just calls me Charlie."
"Um, h-hey," Misty stammered out.
"Uh, everything cool, babe?"
Being called babe was Olive's thing and Misty was typically annoyed when someone other than her girlfriend did it. She found herself oddly fine with it with Charlie, however. Misty didn't typically go after more masculine woman but there was just something about her that interested her. Maybe she was still reeling from Tina's more overzealous greeting and this new girl's laidback demeanor was just refreshing. Well, whatever it was, Misty did her best to put on a kind smile as she took her eyes away from the floor and said, "No, everything's fine. Sorry, I'm just a little nervous."
"Yeah, Olive said this was your first time. Don't sweat it. We'll eat dinner, have some laughs, and after getting a few drinks in us-"
A shrill yell from the kitchen called, "Don't you give our guests any of that gross, cheap beer of yours! You'll scare them off!"
"Hey, it's just as good as that over-priced grape juice you drink!"
"My wine is quality!"
The two were yelling but Misty could tell there was no real malice in their voices. They seemed like a nice enough couple and Misty could already feel the tension in her body ease away. Still, a drink or two couldn't hurt.
"A glass of wine would be nice," she told Charlie who nodded.
Olive asked for a beer instead and with a wink, Charlie said, "A girl after my own heart," before getting up and making her way into the kitchen.
The two cats sat down on the couch and, the moment their canine companion was out of earshot, Olive said, "So, what do you think? Gorgeous, aren't they? Tina's super cute and did you see Charlie's dick? Damn!"
"Kind of hard not to notice," Misty said with a blush. She wondered if Charlie always walked around like that if if she'd dressed down for their benefit.
Charlie reappeared a moment later with a glass of wine in one hand and a beer in the other. She handed one to each of the girls before taking a seat next to Misty, sandwiching the woman inbetween her girlfriend and a half naked dog she'd only just met. Their bare arms brushed together, Charlie's warmth making Misty happy she'd decided to wear a simple t-shirt that day as opposed to something with long sleeves. They chatted for a bit but it wasn't long before Tina was calling them all to eat and everyone moved to sit at the table in the dining room, Misty and Olive together with Tina and Charlie across from them.
Dinner wasn't anything fancy. Chicken legs, roast potatoes and a side of corn and peas. It still tasted amazing and Misty made a mental note of asking Tina what spices she used for the chicken later.
"So, Olive tells me you've been seeing each other for a year?" Tina said before plopping a potato in her mouth.
Misty gave Olive a loving look as she said, "And it's been an amazing year," that earned her an 'aw' from Tina.
"Charlie and me have been together for five and living for two. We're basically married in every way but legally," the spaniel told her.
Tina told Misty a little more about how they'd met on a dating site and ran a small plant nursery together. While Tina was telling her about what plants were in season, Misty couldn't help how her mind wondered to topics outside of tulips. Biting her lip, Misty finally decided to take the plunge. "Um, Tina? Charlie? Can I ask you two something?"
"Shoot," Charlie said with a mouthful of food.
"How exactly did you two, uh, start all of this. Seeing other people, I mean."
Tina giggle. "No need to be shy, sweetie. We're super open about all of this. As for how it happened, well, we didn't go into this as an open relationship. It just sort of happened a couple of years ago when we met this absolutely adorable mare. She used to come to the nursery all the time and flirt with the both of us like you would not believe. We flirted back but we never really thought much about it at first. Until..."
"Until we both realised we'd developed major crushes on her," Charlie continued. "But neither of us were really gonna do anything about it. We were in a committed relationship, you know? Then one day that sexy mare waltzed right in and asked both of us out right there next to the potting soil."
"The three of us had a long talk about it and figured why not? Although we only dated for a couple of months because she ended up getting this promotion that moved her to another country. It was sad to see her go but we're still thankful for what she brought into our life and helping us realise that monogamy isn't for everyone."
"So, you both dated her? At the same time?" Misty asked.
"Yes, we do prefer doing it that way." Tina gave Charlie a soft smile as she reached out to hold her hand. "We've tried dating people on our own but being in a threeway partnership just feels more equal for us. Not that other ways aren't good for other people but this is what we found works best for us."
Misty knew she was referencing how Olive dated other people while Misty didn't. She knew Olive had told them but having someone mention it out loud still felt a little...embarrassing? She was the only one in the room who had no real experience with any of this and was beginning to feel a little left out. And all the more curious. Misty bit her lip. While curious, she still wasn't entirely sure how she felt about causal flings but the idea of having another serious girlfriend was appealing. Would Tina and Charlie be interested in her in that way? Misty mentally slapped herself. She'd only just met these two, it wasn't time to think about-oh!
Misty nearly jumped out of her seat when she felt a foot brush up against the inside of her jean leg. She looked over at Tina who was still holding Charlie's hand but who's smile now seemed a little more devilish. "We want all this to be enjoyable for you so just tell us if either one of us steps over a line, okay?"
Did Charlie know what Tina was doing? If she did she wasn't saying anything. A small smile played on Misty's lips as she said, "Everything's great so far."
Tina took this as a sign to go further if her foot going any higher was an indication. Her toes were now brushing against Misty's inner thigh, just inches from her groin. She stopped there, most likely more to do with not being able to reach any further than really wanting to stop. Their eyes met and Tina shot her a wink that made Misty's heart skip a beat. She looked out the corner of her eye at Olive who was chatting away with Charlie about something, both blissfully unaware of the game their girlfriends were playing.
"You're joking!" Olive said, laughing at some story Charlie had been telling her.
"I'm dead serious. Tina can tell you, she was there. Right, babe?"
She turned to the spaniel who responded with a laugh and, "How could I forget? I'd never been kicked out of anywhere before."
Misty was surprised how she'd actually been paying attention to the conversation while less than subtly flirting with someone else. Misty's lack of experience when compared to her was really starting to shine through. Then, without warning, she clapped her hands together, nearly causing Misty to fall out of her chair, before saying, "I see everyone's done dinner. Who wants some lemon meringue?"
"Ooh, sounds great," Olive said. "Did you make it yourself?"
"I wish. No, we got it from this cute little bakery down the road that makes the best desserts."
Charlie, Olive, and Tina carried on their conversation, not really talking about anything important but having fun none the less while the dessert was served and quickly devoured. Misty only half paid attention while she ate her piece of pie. It really was delicious but even the softness of the meringue and tartness of the lemon wasn't enough to distract her from her thoughts. What really was tonight all about? Olive had called it a date but just what exactly did that mean for her and the other couple? Were they just spending the night getting to know each other or were the others expecting more to happen? With the way Olive had told her she could leave if she ever got uncomfortable, she meant with sex, right?
Misty's heart was pounding in her ears. Everyone was already finished their dessert, except for her, but she only had two more bites and she'd be done. And then what? Were things going to escalate to upstairs? Did she want it to? Her heart beat faster at the realisation that, yes, she did want it to. She ate her two last mouthfuls.
"You done, sweetie?" Tina asked, pointing to Misty's now clean plate. She gave a small nod and the dog quickly cleaned up everyone's dishes and headed towards the kitchen.
With Tina out the room, Charlie turned to Olive with a predatory grin as she said, "So, beautiful, wanna take this upstairs? We got the spare room all ready."
"Ooh, exciting," Olive giggled. "Can't wait."
"Spare room?" Misty asked with a tilt of her head.
Olive leaned over to place a hand on Misty's thigh and gave it a reassuring squeeze. "We were hoping this night would end with, well, I'm not gonna beat around the bush, sex. You are okay with that, right?"
"Well," Misty's cheeks warmed up. "I figured that's where this was going..."
"You can leave if you want. We still had fun, right? Nice dinner and conversation."
"It would have been if I hadn't spent so much time thinking about where this would all lead," she admitted. "And, honestly? I...I think I want this? I'm scared, sure, I've never had a threesome let alone a foursome but I'm curious and kind of excited."
It was then Tina walked back into the room. "So, what's the plan."
"We're all heading upstairs," Charlie said as she shot Misty a wink. "All of us."
Tina squealed as she ran over and grabbed Misty's hand, pulling her out of her chair. "This is so exciting! I can't believe we get to spend the night with a couple of cuties like you two."
Misty was surprised by her comment. Olive was the attractive one, not her. She didn't think she was ugly but she was fairly plain and definitely not on Olive's level. Misty didn't know if the shock of what she'd said was written on her face but Tina's giddy expression softened as she leaned in. Misty froze as Tina's lips pressed against hers but they were warm and soft and she quickly eased into the kiss.
"Damn, our girls don't waste any time, huh?" Charlie said with a laugh.
Olive wrapped her arms around Charlie's neck and, with a sly smirk, said, "I don't like being outdone. Care to help me with that?"
Tina and Misty broke away from their kiss just in time to see their girlfriends locking lips with Charlie's hands planted firmly on Olive's behind. Much to Misty's surprise she found it actually pretty hot. The air of domination that Charlie exuded as she groped and ground against her partner brought a new and strange heat to her cheeks.
"Watching my Charlie take charge , especially when it's with other women, has always been a major turn on for me," Tina told Misty, her eyes also glued on the two, and Misty couldn't help but nod in agreement.
They broke the kiss and Charlie whispered something into Olive's ear that the other women couldn't hear. Then Olive dropped to her knees.
Misty's heart was beating so fast she was scared it would burst right out of her chest as she watched the love of her lower the front of someone else's underwear, that someone's massive dick springing free, already half hard and ready for what was coming next. Olive stared up at Charlie with wide eyes full of mischief, wrapped her fingers around the base of her cock, holding it in place as she ran her tongue along its side, never breaking eye contact as she did so.
"Typical of Charlie to start before we even head upstairs. Not that I'm complaining," Tina said with a girlish giggle. "And look at Olive go!"
The Siamese had always loved sucking dick, a fact Misty was most appreciative of, and watching her go to town on someone else's was a lot more appealing than she thought it would be. The way her tongue swirled around the head as she fisted the shaft sent a shot of warmth to the pit of her stomach. She just about imploded when Olive removed her hand and, in one swift motion, took her all the way down to the base. Charlie was not a small girl in the slightest and Olive couldn't help but choke as what Misty imagined was the tip of her dick slamming against the back of the cat's throat. But the coughing didn't deter her one bit as she began to bob her head with enthusiasm.
"Now, THAT is impressive. Took me ages to be able to get her all in in one go. Olive's got talent," Tina said and then added in a low whisper, "or maybe she has experience?"
"Not because of me, I'm pretty average," Misty found herself blurting out without thinking. Tina only giggled in response before going back to watching her girlfriend of five years getting head from someone they'd only known a week.
Olive moaned around the meat in her mouth and Misty felt her breath catch in her throat as she noticed Olive's hand had slipped under her shirt and she was now groping at her perfect breasts. It was then Charlie seemed to decide Olive was going a little to slow for her taste and placed a hand on each side of her head to hold her in place as she began moving her hips. The motions were slow at first but they quickly sped up when Charlie realised just how much the other woman could take.
As Charlie relentlessly slammed into the love of her life's face, her cock throbbing down her throat, Misty couldn't help the way her own shaft hardened, begging to be touched by someone, anyone. Her fingers twitched and she was so tempted to just shove her hands into her jeans but held back. She wasn't entirely sure how the etiquette of these things went and wondered if pawing at herself would be seen as impolite. She looked back at Olive with another woman's cock in her mouth and went screw it as she unzipped her jeans.
"Nice undies," she heard Tina giggle as she looked down at the white cotton and pink rose covered panties peaking out from Misty's jeans. "They're adorable just like their wearer."
"T-Thank you," Misty said with a blush, surprising herself at how the compliment was making her more embarrassed than what was going on on the other side of the room.
"I see their antics has gotten you a little excited," Tina said, pointing at Misty's obvious bulge. "Mind if I help?"
Misty gave a small nod and pulled her dick out of its cotton prison, earning her a hungry look from Tina. She pressed herself against Misty's side, the cat's shoulder now nestled neatly between her breasts, effectively trapping her and making her dominant arm useless. She clearly wanted to take control as much as her girlfriend did and Misty found she was okay with that. Especially when the dog curled her fingers around her shaft and began to pump.
Misty moaned as she watched the other two continue to go at it while having her own shaft played with. She was embarrassingly hard already and had no idea how long she'd last. Tina nuzzled her cheek with a cold nose that made her shiver and she said, "Let go. It's okay. We have all night to enjoy ourselves, after all."
Misty shivered at her words as her tip was leaking pre like mad at her voice. Tina pressed her thumb against the moist slit and began spreading the liquid around her head, causing Misty to do a full body shudder and groan. It was then Charlie threw her head back in a low moan before thrusting into Olive's face one more time. A small dribble of cum slid out the side of her girlfriend's mouth as she managed to swallow the rest. The sight of Olive pulling away and licking her wet, sticky lips as she looked up at Charlie with a heated edge to her eyes, was more than enough to send her over the edge herself.
"Wow, babe, you shot far," Olive said as she stood up and made her way towards her. Misty was still in post orgasm bliss when her girlfriend leaned in and kissed her. Her tongue quickly made its way into her mouth, Misty able to taste the other woman on her. Charlie had her own distinct flavour and she wanted more of it, wondering if she'd get the chance to take it right from the source.
"As hot as your little makeout session is...anyone wanna go upstairs?" Charlie said to the two.
Olive pulled away and gave Misty one last peck on the nose before running off upstairs, Charlie giving her rear a quick slap as she ran by before going after the now squealing and giggling feline. Tina took Misty's hand and the two women followed with Misty's softening dick still hanging free as the day it was born.
She was led to a room upstairs that was empty save for a large dark blue blanket in the middle of the room on the floor with several pillows piled on it and a simple black travel suitcase next to it. The other three women wasted no time in getting undressed and soon Misty was the only one in any kind of clothing, a faux pas that was quickly rectified as Olive pulled down her jeans and underwear, causing the woman to squeak from surprise.
"Come on, baby doll, no need to be shy," a very naked Charlie said to her with a smirk before lying stomach down on the blanket splayed out before them, resting her folded arms on a pillow.
Misty stepped out of her jeans and undies before pulling off her shirt and tossing it to the side. Olive gave a loud whoop as she made her way around Misty's back to unclip her bra. It, too, fell to the floor, leaving Misty just as naked as everyone else. Olive stepped around her and hugged her from behind, her enormous breasts pressing against Misty along with her dick sliding inbetween her cheeks. Having not gotten off earlier, Olive was still rock hard. Misty bit her bottom lip as she pressed up against her, causing her throbbing cock to move against her, its underside pressing against her hole. Olive brought her arms around to grope at Misty's breasts and pinch her nipples until they began to grow hard.
"Damn, that's hot," Charlie said as she watched them over her shoulder. "But my dick's getting hard against and how about one of you solve that problem by fucking me? Sound good?"
Charlie lifted her tail to reveal a bright pink butt plug. Charlie saw Misty gaping at the toy and added, "Yeah, pink's not really my colour but Tina wanted me to wear it and there's no way I can say no to that face."
Tina sat down next to Charlie and gave her a quick kiss. She then motioned to the travel case and said, "There's more toys in there if anyone is interested."
Olive's eyes immediately lit up as she bounced merrily over to the case. Misty missed her partner's touch but her interest was soon brought to Charlie who was moaning as Tina pulled out her plug with a loud squelch. Her hole was gaping thanks to the toy and it hungrily twitched, clearly wanting to be filled again. Misty could feel the blood rushing to her cock once more as she began to grow hard.
"Ooh, is this strawberry scented lube?" Olive said as she pulled out a bottle with faintly pink liquid inside. She popped open the cap and gave it a sniff, adding, "It smells amazing. Can we use this?"
"Use whatever you want," Tina said. "That's why we brought it all out, after all."
Olive began rummaging in the case, letting out the occasional ooh and ah, making Misty really curious as to what was actually in there. In the end, she didn't take anything else out of the case and just brought over the lovely smelling lube, quickly coating her fingers in it. "Charlie's already all lubed up and stretched, right?" she asked Tina who nodded. Misty was a little disappointed that Olive hadn't seemed to want to play with any toys but maybe they could save that for the next time. The fact she was thinking of a next time made Misty's dick twitch.
"Yes but a little bit more of the good stuff couldn't hurt," Tina told her, motioning towards the bottle.
Charlie laughed, "Want revenge for throat fucking you by going after my tail? Well, I ain't complaining."
Olive shook her head as she smiled, "I'm not gonna be the one fucking you. She is," she said as she pointed a lube covered finger towards Misty.
"M-Me?!" was all the grey cat could blubber out as Olive nodded.
"Honestly, its always been a fantasy of mine to see you with someone else. When I saw Tina giving you that handjob out the corner of my eye..." Olive gave a dreamy sigh. "You would not believe how hot it made me. So, would you do this for me, please?"
Misty looked towards Charlie and Tina who both enthusiastically nodded. Then, with a smile, Misty said, "Well, tonight has been all about new experiences so why not?"
Olive gave her a big kiss on the cheek before grabbing her dick with her lube covered hand to cover all of Misty from tip to base. Once fully lubed up, Misty knelt down behind Charlie to have her erect member guided to the Rottweiler's hole, the cat sliding into her already stretched entrance with ease. Misty gasped as the heat engulfed her, so distracted that she didn't even notice Tina had moved to sit behind her. Misty was placing her hands on Charlie's hips to study herself when she felt her tail being lifted my Olive's slippery lube fingers while a warm tongue pressed against her own hole. She looked over her shoulder to find Tina inbetween her cheeks, happily lapping at her puckered entrance. Olive let go of her tail and it stayed there, not daring to go down in fear it would stop the magic that was Tina's tongue.
"I mentioned to them how much you loved getting eaten out and Tina was more than happy to oblige," Olive told her with a sultry smile.
A breathy "Thank you" was all Misty could muster as pleasure hit her from both ends. She then watched as Olive coated her own dick with the sweet smelling substance, running her hand up and down her shaft to cover it completely. Misty couldn't help her dick twitching at the site and Olive no doubt knew how much it turned her on if the wink she shot her was any indication. She then moved to position herself behind Tina and Misty's eyes widened as she slammed her hips into the spaniel, pushing her forward and caused a train reaction of her snout pressing against Misty who, in turn, slammed against Charlie.
Tina moaned as she gave a few more licks before pulling out. Her moving to get on her knees and then press her dick against Misty's entrance wasn't what the cat had been expecting to happen next. The small dog rested her chin on Misty's neck as she whispered in her ear, breath hot against her, "Olive told us you're something of a masochist and that you love going at it with little prep."
"I-I'm not a masochist! I just like the friction," Misty tried to defend herself but Tina was having none of it.
"It's all right, sweetie," she laughed. "No shame here."
Charlie piped up, "Hell, yeah. We're all kinky freaks here."
"I've seen what's in that box. She's not kidding" Olive said.
"Hey, Olive," Charlie said. "How about you go behind Tina and we really get this fuck train going?"
Tina nodded in agreement. "I'm not wearing a plug but I did prep earlier just in case. Maybe add a little more lube and I'll be all ready." She then whispered in Misty's ear, "We're not all like a certain little kitty who can take it with practically no stretching or lube."
Misty's breathing was heavy, both from Charlie in front and Tina from behind. She wanted someone, anyone, to just move already. When she heard Tina gasp, she knew Olive's slippery fingers were doing their magic. Tina's soft moans that followed were heavenly, especially so close to her ear. It seemed Charlie, however, was also getting impatient. She rocked back against Misty with a growl, demanding she move. She wanted to, holy shit did she want to, but should she wait for Olive and Tina? How did a fuck train even work?!
"Oh, God, Olive, yes!" Tina moaned as she thrust forward into Misty without warning, causing her, in turn, to press deeper into Charlie.
"Damn, that's good," Charlie groaned as she buried her face into the pillow.
Misty had to agree. She'd never taken it from both sides before and with Tina's arms around around her, the overwhelming physical contact was making her light headed. She gasped as Olive thrust forward and made Tina move again. She took the hint and pushed into Charlie and soon the women were thrusting in time with one another, the room filling with the sounds of their moaning and skin slapping against skin.
"You feel amazing, Misty," Tina said in a lust filled voice against the cat's ear.
"Hell yeah she does!" Charlie piped up enthusiastically. With a particularly hard thrust she gasped, "And she really knows how to use that dick, holy fuck."
Misty's face was red from both arousal and embarrassment, unsure of how to take everyone's compliments. Then Olive decided to add, "Now you know why I can't get enough of that dick and that arse."
"You weren't lying when you said how good it was," Tina said with a harsher than normal thrust, nearly throwing Misty off balance. Misty knew logically that the realisation that they'd been talking about her skills in bed should have been humiliating but, instead, she got a kind of thrill from it. She'd actually been boasting about her to others. Misty couldn't help how hard her next thrust was, lost in her lust.
"Fuck, just like that," Charlie moaned.
"I can't take this anymore," Olive said before removing her fingers. But Tina's hole wasn't left empty for long with Olive wasting no time in sliding her dick in, her pace immediately going off at full steam.
The speed of the women amped up, all taken over by the room full of the smell of sex and the wet slapping of skin. When Tina let out one final gasp and released into her, Misty's own orgasm taking over as the warm liquid filled her hole, she knew that she wouldn't be able to live with doing this only once.
Once all the women were spent, they pulled out and collapsed onto the blanket in a satisfied heap. Misty made a sound of surprise as Charlie grabbed her and pulled her into a hug, pressing her head into her breasts while Charlie nuzzled the fur atop her head. With a giggle, Tina said, "She may not look it but Charlie's always been a cuddler. And it looks like she's picked you to be her latest victim."
"Less talk, more snuggles," Charlie said as she raised her arm not currently holding Misty in a death grip. Tina took the hint and curled up next to her partner. Not wanting to be left out, Olive flopped down beside Misty to also wrap her arms around her in a hug.
The room grew silent as the four women bathed in their afterglow. It wasn't silent for long, however, as Charlie said to the cat in her arms, "So, babe, what ya think? Not bad, huh?"
"Not bad indeed," Misty said with a satisfied sigh.
"So, Misty," Tina started, sounding nervous and not like the bold woman Misty had known so far. "Charlie and I really like Olive and after meeting you, well, I think I speak for the both of us when I say you're a pretty awesome person..."
"She wants to know if you wanna date us," Charlie finished what her partner was trying to say.
"Date you? You mean, as in be your girlfriend?" Misty asked.
"Yeah!" Olive threw in. "The three of us talked a lot this past week and I'd love to be their actual girlfriend but I said I wanted to bring you along on our first official date to see first if maybe you'd be interested?"
Olive looked at Misty with hope in her eyes, the other cat sighing as she said, "Wow, you three move fast. Listen, while what we did was fun, that was only our first date and I like to know someone a bit longer for I commit to anything." The other women looked absolutely crestfallen at Misty's comment. A wide smile broke out on Misty's face as she added, "But I had a lot of fun today and not just with the sex. You two are fun to hangout with and if we had a few more dates I wouldn't entirely be against the idea of dating you two."
Olive squealed as she squeezed Misty even tighter, Charlie doing the same. Misty couldn't believe she might end up getting not one but two new girlfriends out of all this. But as Tina and Olive happily chatted away over her about their next date and Charlie continued to nuzzle her, she figured maybe having so many girlfriends wouldn't be so bad.