A Split Decision For Candice

Story by Joshiah on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

#54 of Incest Stories (Others)

We ran some incest themed YCH auctions a few months back. This is the first of the two!

Enjoy this naughty little tale of Candice being indecisive in her life, as usual...but this time, about which of her brother's cocks is better! Naturally, she can't make up her mind, even after trying both of them on for size.

Commissions are OPEN! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zgOEtZEtYYWCKsnRBjAk60wySlaWvmFjwSFU7l6tx24/edit?usp=sharing

We're also running three different YCH auctions for Shark Week! Check them out! http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/8819782/ https://www.sofurry.com/view/1354571 https://www.patreon.com/posts/shark-week-ych-20335208

Don't forget to join our Patreon for early access to posts like this: https://www.patreon.com/Joshiah

As always, read, comment and enjoy!


"No...hm. I'm still not sure."

Candice was famous around her small, quiet neighborhood for her sense of indecision. It was a safer community growing up: children were allowed to run free, even at a young age, and everyone seemed to know everyone else on a personal level, without being too involved in their private business.

Her reputation was deserved; she was the kind of kid who would make everyone else wait in line as she picked the absolutely perfect ice cream treat in the summer, and during the winter, she had to have just the right path to sled down, when she was with the other kids on the hill.

Into her teenage years, and even well into her early adulthood, Candice refused to change her ways. She rarely dated, finding so few men met the requirements that she set out for herself, rather than the demands of her overprotective father, and when she took a job, it was only when the hours worked around her schedule.

Even in the bedroom, she was terribly picky, and the kneeling hybrid was still tapping her chin in thought as she gazed up the length of one cock, glistening with her saliva, while she gingerly bounced another in an open palm.

"Yours is a little brighter red, but your knot is a little wider...you both taste fantastic, and you've got plenty of precum, but...goodness, I haven't had a decision this tough in years!"

"More like five minutes," her brother, Andy, was quick to taunt her.

Even in a community where fences were just low enough for everyone to see into the backyard, sometimes it was easy to miss the trees for the forest; no one had any sort of a clue that Candice preferred the company of her two brothers in the bedroom, from the neighbors who so often waved at the friendly trio from their yard, to the multiple sets of parents who raised them.

Candice was the middle, golden child. Her brother Andy was the offspring of a first marriage, a hybrid of a bear and a monkey, himself. Her other brother, Psy, was a purebred German Shepherd, and the result of two different sets of parents meeting was a daughter who was every bit as tall as her father, and every bit as thick as her mother.

Her defense of the act was the same as it ever was: they were all related by common threads, but with so many different parents involved, it could hardly be considered incest.

Knowing that the real world disagreed was motivation enough to keep their acts a secret, and the trials of adulthood were supplying plenty of privacy for Candice to figure out who she was going to be spending more of her time with.

Her poor brothers had no idea that they were being played for fools the entire time.

"The way she makes decisions, I'm gonna need a skin graft before she picks one of us," Psy replied. Snickering and gazing down upon his sister with a cocked brow, he watched his member bouncing first of its own vitality, and then with her open palm, as she continued to consider it.

Finally releasing her chin, Candice brushed the long, tan bangs from in front of her chocolate eyes and nodded to Psy. "Age before beauty, right, little bro?"

"If that's how you really feel," he agreed. He wasn't one to argue, knowing that once Candice finally did make up her mind, it was very difficult to change it, and she wasn't afraid to go after what she truly wanted.

Her paw released his member and she shot up from her knees, right past the still dripping length of Andy's member, and the hybrid merely crossed his arms and rolled his eyes as he stepped aside, watching Candice bounce right into the standing arms of her younger, but certainly larger sibling.

"For the moment, anyway. Better hurry before I change my mind," she teased, offering up a quick wink, but that wasn't enough to convince Psy that he was in the clear.

Seizing the moment and her flesh in one swoop, Psy hooked his open paw down around the back of her thigh and pushed her over, right against the edge of her fluffy, comforting mattress. "Don't need to tell me twice, sis. I'm not taking sloppy seconds on this one!"

"You got lucky ," Andy suggested, keeping a tight grip around the base of his cock as he watched from the side. He knew that Psy wasn't going to last too long, but that was entirely by Candice's devious paws: privacy was plentiful, but fleeting, and she'd already been wrapped around both of her brothers more times than she could count.

It was that glorious, creamy finale that was going to be different this time around, as she finally defeated her qualms about letting a male finish inside of her.

"You're gonna get lucky too, y'know. Gimme five minutes."

" If that," Candice teased her younger brother, all while crooking a pawtip at him to move his hips forward.

Hovering above her parted, tempting folds, Psy bent his knees and angled his hips right at her womanhood, his eyes trading glances with her smooth, alluring labia and the comforting orbs of chocolate brown that always tried, and usually succeeded to sucker him in.

It was business as usual when the tapered, drooling tip of his canine length brushed against the seductive part of her petals and eased past, moving as slowly as she would allow him to.

"Time is of the essence, little bro," Candice reminded him. She refused to pant or gasp just from the subtle poke, but when her ankles hooked around his rump, and her claws dug right into the smooth, sensitive flesh beneath, she couldn't fight a cry of delight, as her brother lunged forward in shock and utterly speared her on his rod.

With her head thrown back into the sheets, Candice was every bit the picture of the goddess her brothers made her out to be, as long, flowing locks of sandy tan sprawled like a halo around a gorgeous visage, and radiant pleasure filled her smile.

The sight alone left Psy hunched over her body, pounding his cock desperately into her sex without any further warmup. They'd been playing for hours, all building up to this final act, but even then, he didn't want to slide in and burn out in mere seconds, even when he could feel his gorgeous sibling clenching and squeezing around his length with orgasmic reflex.

"That's a d-dirty little trick, Candice..."

The canine-ursine hybrid giggled, and her wincing eyes opened with a narrowed, seductive gaze. "Just...w-what trick is that, little brother?" she asked, all while squeezing his shaft with such a desperate grip that Psy was left struggling against his impending climax.

It was a wasted effort, and he knew it; the moment that he stopped trying was when his stomach tightened, his sack squeezed around full, swollen orbs, and one paw was forced to grip the base of his knot, knowing that he'd tie with her if he didn't stop himself.

"You f-fuckin' know what!" he growled, and his tongue lolled over the side of his open muzzle as he panted with all of the lustful, canine desperation that he could manage. Precum drizzled down from the tip of his older brother's cock as Andy watched on with appreciation of Psy's efforts, and Candice, for her part, was left beyond words as she experienced the rush of heated, gushing seed, spilling into her womanhood and painting her inner muscles for the very first time.

I should have let them start doing this to me _ years _ ago.

Her thought would have been all of the compliments that either one needed, but her usually snarky expression was left with a small, silent pair of lips hanging open, and her eyes staring almost blankly at the ceiling. She'd always known her own body fairly well, and thought she understood the depths of her vaginal passage, but as her own brother's cum rushed up into the chamber of her womb, she knew an internal warmth unlike anything she'd ever imagined.

Her lips just managed to curl into a grin once more as Psy stood above her and held the base of his knot, whimpering like the dog that he was and watching his excess cum spray across the thick lines of her tummy and the delicious, smooth orbs of her breasts, and wonderful as that was...

...She needed a repeat performance so badly, no words would do it justice.

"Ready for round two so soon? Guess my little brother wasn't up to the task," Andy claimed, having seen a quick gaze from his panting sister, and a small hook of her finger thereafter. "Good thing I'm still here to show him how it's done."

Stepping back and slumping down to the floor with a grin, Psy shook his head dismissively. "G...go on, bro. Lecture me."

Making sure that his tail was lifted nice and high, just to taunt Psy with the possibilities of what else they could do, Andy strolled right over to his resting sister and leaned over her, just as his younger sibling had. The smooth, black fur upon his tummy created a sensual contrast between the pearly, white streaks of cum on her own, and even when it stuck to his fur, he didn't hesitate at the chance to spear her on his length.

Andy made the rounds in their neighborhood, sleeping with plenty of other suitors in his years; he always seemed to come back to Candice, and like a good, affectionate sibling, she was always waiting for him with an eager grin and a playful wag of her short, thick tail of caramel.

"Lecture him all you want," she finally piped up again, "But hurry up and fuck me w-while I'm still cumming...I wanna see how long I c-can make this orgasm last!"

There could be no purpose more glorious to Andy, who wasn't so slow and easy with her to start. He knew what Candice could handle, and her fangs braced together in a wicked grin as he gripped her lower back and hoisted her right up from the bed, holding her body up against his own and creating a platform with his lap.

"Let's make it last until Mom and Dad get home. I want them to hear you shouting my name."

Andy carried himself so confidently in the bedroom that his kinky, lewd jabs always caught Candice on the blindside, and she could feel a renewed warmth of arousal spreading through her sex as the older hybrid released her, allowing her already pouting folds to easily spread around his cock and then envelop it in one brief, fell swoop.

Slapping down against his hips and gazing between their bodies to see the wonderfully sensual display, Candice sucked in a deep breath at being so completely stuffed, and managed only to gaze at her older sibling with desperate eyes before her climax was elongated.

Toned, quivering arms flew around his neck as Candice leaned further into his embrace and bit down on the side of his neck, knowing that she'd lose the battle against her chorus of moans sooner than later.

"Keep going..."

Soft, easy jabs from the hip were just a tease from Andy, who was already on the verge, but could still play the devious part. "What was that, sister mine?"

" Keep going ," she growled into his ear, her claws digging at the sensitive flesh between his shoulder blades. "It's s-so good...making me cum again...so k-keep fucking going!"

Those desperate, sinful cries were just what Andy needed to reach his climax, though a few more thrusts would have done the trick, as well; they simply didn't carry the same forbidden delight that his sister's moans did, and as her inner muscles fluttered and clenched at random around his shaft, his length throbbed and trembled as thick, plentiful cum burst from the tip and joined the already slippery mess that Psy left before him.

The purebred was watching from the floor with a grin, still gently pumping his own length to the show as he rode out the last waves of his climax, and with some jealousy, he watched excess volume pour out of Candice's folds and drip down over the smooth, short fur upon her rump before it dripped to the floor, while stronger bursts of ejaculate sprayed right from her cunt as Andy thrust himself in, making a terrible mess of his inner thighs.

If he wasn't lucky, Psy would have to clean that mess up with his tongue instead of watching Candice do it, but all of that would come down to her verdict, and she was still panting as her older brother cradled her in close, and settled down to the floor.

"Hard to compete with a performance like that," Psy admitted, all while he squeezed the base of his knot and prepared for the worst. "I suppose I'm on clean up duty, then?"

Andy was already grinning with earthly delight, but his lips spread wider at a perceived victory, even as Candice sat upright in his lap and started to catch her breath.

"Hmmm..."

Even right after getting plowed by both of her brothers, Candice was right back to her usual, indecisive ways.

"I dunno! You were both pretty good, but it's not fair for one of you to get to go first, and not the other."

Andy and Psy shared an exasperated glare, before turning their stares back on Candice, who couldn't help a quick, teasing giggle.

"Guess we'll just have to try this again tomorrow..."