The Dalton Return of Kurt Hummel

Story by Wild the Helldalmatian on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Yo everybody! Wild here. Now, check out this new Glee story from me which will be featuring one of my favorite couples in all of Glee. Kurt and Sebastian, with a special appearance of the Dalton Academy Warblers. This is an AU of season 4 where Kurt visits Dalton to see his friends at Dalton, but, along the way, he meets up with his old rival Sebastian, and, gets the attention of not only Sebastian, but the Warblers new captain, Hunter Clarington. But when Kurt challenges Sebastian and Hunter's authority and taunts them, the two take matters in their own hands.

Songs included: Clarity by Zedd and Foxes, sung by Lucas and Jeff (Lucas is an OC Warbler of mine who is played by James Maslow of Big Time Rush. Jeff is a real Glee character who is played by R5 singer and brother of former Disney Star Ross Lynch, Riker Lynch.)

Light Em Up (My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark) by Fall Out Boy, sung by Kurt, Hunter and Sebastian.

Glee, songs and characters are not owned by me, except my OC's.

Hope you enjoy the story. No bad comments please, if you enjoy please fave, comment, and vote thank you!


If there was any school, that made Kurt Hummel feel like he was at home, it was the prestigious Dalton Academy in Westerville, Ohio. He had a call from one of his ex-Warbler buddies Jeff to come for a visit while the Warblers rehearsed.

At first, Kurt was reluctant. Sure he was happy to visit some of his old Dalton buddies like Jeff, Nick, Trent, Lucas, and many others. Since he graduated from McKinley last year and finally got his dream of being in New York come true, there was bound to be a bunch of new Warblers to see who have great talent and voices. But, there was always one black sheep in the flock that had bad intentions aka, Kurt's rival, Sebastian Smythe.

If there was any other person who Kurt had disliked anymore than the idiotic, pig-headed, obnoxious, dumbass jocks back at McKinley, it was Sebastian. Sure some of the Warblers and his ex Blaine had texted him, saying Sebastian had 'changed' but that still didn't change Kurt's opinion on the green eyed boy. Even though Sebastian did apologize for Dave's attempted suicide, played nice at Regionals, and kept on the down-low, Kurt still had his doubts. But what surprised Kurt, was that Lucas had texted him the Warblers had a new captain, saying he was some ex-military school student, now this was something Kurt had to see.

He pulled his Navigator up to the Dalton Academy gates and smiled, Kurt, being a person of fashion and trends, always liked the way Dalton looked. Its architecture always astounded him. It always reminded Kurt of a medieval castle. As he opened the doors, he wasn't surprised when he heard a hum of familiar voices. Kurt giggled, 'Must be practicing for Sectionals.' He thought. Walking to the Warblers rehearsal room, he was amazed to see Lucas and Jeff now leading.

Lucas: High dive into frozen waves where the past comes back to life

Lucas stood in the front and sang softly, it always amazed Kurt that he was not the only counter-tenor in the Warblers but Lucas was also one. In the corner he could see Sebastian sitting on a desk, smirking that irritatingly but, charming meerkat like smirk at him. 'Charming?! No! I'd never find that craigslist smelling, horse toothed meerkat charming.' Kurt thought hastily, a big blush on his cheeks but shook it off, trying to focus on the Warblers.

Lucas: Fight fear for the selfish pain, it was worth it every time

Hold still right before we crash 'cause we both know how this ends

A clock ticks 'til it breaks your glass and I drown in you again

At clock, Lucas and the Warblers moved their arms and hands like the hands of a clock ticking. Kurt smiled, 'Heh, their choreography is always on spot.' He thought.

'Cause you are the piece of me I wish I didn't need

Chasing relentlessly, still fight and I don't know why

If our love is tragedy, why are you my remedy?

If our love's insanity, why are you my clarity?

Soon, the Warblers were now all over the place, dancing with everything they got while Lucas and Jeff harmonized with each other.

If our love is tragedy, why are you my remedy?

If our love's insanity, why are you my clarity?

Jeff smiled as he took his spot and began singing. Sebastian just hanging in the back smirking while he watched the blonde boy sing. Kurt was amazed, this was the first time Jeff ever had a solo.

Jeff: Walk on through a red parade and refuse to make amends

It cuts deep through our ground and makes us forget all common sense

Don't speak as I try to leave 'cause we both know what

we'll choose

Kurt heard everything, to him, Jeff's voice was as sweet as honey but nice and low, but not too low. For the glasz eyed boy, both Jeff and Lucas deserved this. Since there would be times any members of the Warblers would have a big time chance for a solo. At 'leave', Jeff slowly walked away from Lucas and right into the arms of Nick who smiled at his boyfriend. But, Jeff playfully backs off and walked to Lucas who held the blondes hand.

Lucas: If you pull then I'll push too deep and I'll fall right back to you

The two then stood side-by-side and sang together while Sebastian, who finally got up and sauntered over to Kurt, harmonizing to him.

Lucas and Jeff: 'Cause you are the piece of me I wish I didn't need

Chasing relentlessly, still fight and I don't know why

If our love is tragedy, why are you my remedy?

If our love's insanity, why are you my clarity?

(Hey-ay, hey-ay-ay. Hey-ay, hey-ay-ay. Hey-ay, hey-ay-ay. Hey-ay, hey)

The warblers soon all danced together in a tango like style while Kurt smiled and decided to join in.

Lucas: Why are you my clarity?

Jeff: Why are you my remedy?

Lucas: Why are you my clarity?

Jeff: Why are you my remedy?

Kurt took the center and sang with his two friends, holding their hands.

Kurt: Jeff, and Lucas: If our love is tragedy, why are you my remedy?

If our love's insanity, why are you my clarity?

The warblers and Kurt soon all harmonized and finished the song with a stomp. Kurt giggled and turned to the boys. "That was awesome guys! Really nice song choice!" He said. Jeff happily hugged Kurt in a bearhug. "Oh Kurtsie! I missed you I nissed you I missed you!" He squealed. Kurt just smiled and petted the blonde. "I know Jeffie, I missed you too." Then gave Lucas a high-five, another hug to Nick and pat on the shoulder to Trent. "So, how's New York treating you Kurt?" Trent asked. "Oh my god, it is so good. And, I have my own loft that I'm living with Rachel. She and I got it in Bushwick. And let me tell you, the loft is big and has a lot of space! Maybe when you guys graduate, you can visit me!" Kurt smiled, the boys cheered until, it was broken by a voice, walking into the room was a new Warbler. He was at Sebastian's height, but his hair was not as gelled as Sebastian's, it was nicely sticking up in spikes. And, for some reason, the look in his eyes intimidated Kurt a little, even the natural vibe of this guy made Kurt a little nervous.

"So, you're...the famous Kurt Hummel?" The boy asked. "Y-Yes I'm Kurt Hummel." Kurt said nervously. "Heh, well, well, well, if it isn't Ohio's resident princess boy, Kurt Hummel." Sebastian's voice was heard as he walked from behind the the approaching boy. Kurt rolled his eyes and smirked, "And, if isn't Dalton and Ohio's resident playboy meerkat manwhore, Sebastian Smythe." Kurt sneered. Sebastian held his hand to his chest, "Aww Kurt, you wound me." Sebastian mock whined. "The only thing that ever wound you is your giant ass ego." Kurt replied. The boy, while he was interested in this little exchange between Sebastian and Kurt, separated them before things got ugly.

"Sebastian, back off." He ordered. Sebastian rolled his eyes but backed off. "Kurt, I'm Hunter Clarington and, I'm not even remotely, bi-curious." Hunter introduced, but, Kurt wasn't fooled. His gaydar sometimes never failed him. Even when he spent time with Sam and Puck at his house ever since he let his Dad allowed Puck back into the house. He had sit on both Puck and Sam's laps, he even allowed them to touch his ass which was just teasing spanks, pinches and playful gropes. "You sure about that, cause, my gaydar says otherwise." Kurt snarked, "But, am I correct to assume you're the Warblers new captain?" He asked. "Yes I am. After the Warblers loss at Regionals to your former team, I intend to get the Warblers to win Nationals by any means, necessary." Hunter said, now standing chest to chest with Kurt. Sebastian and the others watched in both interest and fright. Cause, Hunter had intimidated them, but, yet Kurt was standing up to him. The Warblers and Sebastian all knew Kurt's very well known Ice Queen attitude. Hell, Kurt goes toe-to-toe with Sebastian in the bitch department.

"So, I guess the Warblers are under new management since Sebastian's stepped down?" Kurt asked. "Actually, I'm now co-captain now Kurt, and, when Hunter's busy or he has something going on, I'm still in charge." Sebastian said with his usual swagger as he stood by Hunter. Kurt snorted, "Wow, good luck trying to find a spotlight big enough for both of you. And, just when I thought your ego couldn't get any bigger Sebastian. Even though you're now co-captain, you still have enough arrogance to cover the Nile river." Kurt sassed. "Oh, you still think that I haven't changed, Princess?" Sebastian taunted. "Oh please, a tiger wouldn't even change its stripes for you Bas." Kurt teased. "And, Hunter, I think you're little reign won't last, Sebastian pretty much had the Warblers under his thumb." continued Kurt teasingly. This surprisingly made both Sebastian and Hunter blush at the taunting words from Kurt.

Shaking the blushes off, both boys narrowed their eyes at the brunette. "Face it boys, you lost your touch." Kurt smirked. "Oh? Alright, then, why don't we prove you wrong? Me and Hunter, against you in a sing off Kurt?" Sebastian challenged. "Alright boys. Bring it on." Kurt said. "And, the song we're doing is....Light Em Up, by Fall Out Boy." Hunter said. "Okay, hope you can catch up." Kurt said.

The three, along with the rest of the Warblers, stood outside. Sebastian and Hunter on one side while Kurt stood on the other. Giving each other their best poker faces, soon they brought their hands together and clapped altogether.

Kurt, Sebastian and Hunter: Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

They all harmonized, and soon enough, in their minds, the atmosphere and world around them changed. Kurt, Hunter and Sebastian standing in front of a roaring, blazing fire, wearing tribal style outfits, covered in warpaint. It was Hunter who started the sing off with Sebastian backing him up while Kurt watched with intense eyes.

Hunter: B-B-B-Be careful making wishes in the dark, dark

Can't be sure when they've hit their mark

And besides in the mean, mean time

I'm just dreaming of tearing you apart

Hunter then raised his arms up with the fire roaring behind him, two silhouettes of the Devil behind him and Sebastian as Hunter sang. Sebastian took his turn while Kurt managed to keep up with them in the dancing.

Sebastian: I'm in the de-details with the devil

So now the world can never get me on my level

Sebastian climbed up a tree and flipped off the branch landing next to Kurt who, held him in a tango-like hold as the two strutted across the ground with Kurt now finally singing, as Kurt sang, Hunter was now amazed and impressed with how high a voice as Kurt's can sing in such a fast-paced but hardcore song such as this.

Kurt: I just gotta get you off the cage

I'm a young lover's rage

Gonna need a spark to ignite

Soon all three boys joined together in a triangle as the fire was raging in front of them.

Kurt, Sebastian, Hunter: My songs know what you did in the dark

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa.

In the dark, dark

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa.

In the dark, dark.

The boys soon danced around the fire like Hawaiian fire dancers, holding sticks they picked up and twirled them like batons. Spinning around as Kurt took his turn, throwing the stick back in the fire, now holding his sai swords.

Kurt: All the writers keep writing what they write

Somewhere another pretty vein just dies

Kurt then laid on the ground like he died and arched his back, imagining the grass was now burnt to a crisp behind him as he danced him while he spun the sai swords in his hands.

Kurt: I've got the scars from tomorrow and I wish you could see

That you're the antidote to everything except for me, me.

Soon, both Sebastian and Hunter took their turns as they spun around Kurt, all three glaring at each other with a determined, intense stare in their eyes. Kurt's determined glasz eyes met Sebastian's fiery emerald green eyes and Hunter's intense amber brown eyes as Sebastian stepped Kurt and wrapped his arms around Kurt's bare stomach.

Sebastian: A constellation of tears on your lashes

Burn everything you love, then burn the ashes

Sebastian sang as he trailed his fingers down Kurt's cheeks, pretending they were tear marks while Hunter stood in front of Kurt.

Hunter: In the end everything collides

My childhood spat back out the monster that you see

Soon they all separated and sang together again.

Hunter, Kurt, Sebastian: My songs know what you did in the dark

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

In the dark, dark

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

In the dark, dark

Soon, they all met each other in the middle and clapped their hands to the beat, Kurt glaring at his rivals with his determined gaze while Hunter now had a snarl on his features while Sebastian had that infuriating smirk.

Hunter, Kurt, Sebastian: My songs know what you did in the dark

(My songs know what you did in the dark)

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

So light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

Light 'em up, up, up

I'm on fire

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

In the dark, dark

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

In the dark, dark

Oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa, oh, oh, whoa

Soon, the vision faded as Kurt, Sebastian and Hunter stared each other down, breathing heavily. "Well?" They asked. "I-It's a tie!" Trent said, astounded. "Whatever, it doesn't matter, but, I gotta say, I'm impressed Kurt, I never imagined someone like you would keep up to the beat of a Fall Out Boy song." Hunter said. "Well, I'm not all Lady Gaga, show-tunes and high-fashion you know." Kurt remarked. "I'll sometimes be in the mood for a little rock n roll, especially Fall Out Boy, which by the way, that song, Light Em Up, is from Fall Out Boys album, Save Rock and Roll, which by the way is a great album." Kurt continued. The two turned to Sebastian, "Well, meerkat, is there any input you wanna say?" Kurt asked tauntingly. Sebastian, was starting to get annoyed by the meerkat taunt but smirked. "Alright, you officially out gayed yourself Kurt and that song made you less of a princess." Sebastian taunted. Kurt just rolled his eyes but smiled as he sat down, relaxing on the grass.

"I never realized how beautiful outside Dalton is...looks so peaceful." Kurt said. Sebastian sat down next to him. "I...honestly agree with you Kurt. I mean, living in Paris, I've been to a few countryside parks and grasslands, but, honestly, Dalton is beautiful." Hunter just stood by them as they watched the grass and trees sway. "So, I'm guessing its true you and Blaine broke up?" Sebastian asked. "Yeah, I mean, I gave him everything I had, but how does he repay me, by openly admitting that he had been seeing someone. A warbler by the name of Eli." Kurt growled. Sebastian narrowed his eyes, even he himself was thinking Blaine had lost his touch and was getting boring. Hunter himself had heard of the so-called great Blaine Anderson, but, after what Jeff, Lucas, Nick, Sebastian and everyone else told him, he was starting to think twice on letting Blaine back. They were gonna win Sectionals, Regionals, and gain a Nationals trophy without Blaine.

"What was even worse, was that Blaine kept on blaming me for some cheating with Chandler, which was ridiculous! It was just harmless, friendly, flirty texting!" Kurt lamented. Sebastian huffed, even he took offense to that. Even though he didn't do relationships, he'd never cheat on someone. Sure he'd love to do some naughty sexting and do some flirty texts, he'd never stoop so low as to accuse someone of cheating through playful harmless texts. "Are you kidding me? That is messed up, and, I've never been in a relationship, but some of friends of mine back in my school had relationships of their own and they'd never do that." Hunter said. "If you think that was bad, Blaine had the audacity to look at my phone!" Kurt snarled. Sebastian found himself getting turned on by Kurt's fiery attitude. Sure he found it a little annoying but, when he heard about the big Klaine break-up, Sebastian had been fighting for feelings he had for Kurt. Sure he was chasing after Blaine, but when Jeff, Nick and Lucas told him about Kurt, Sebastian had been contemplating his intentions. Same with Hunter, evem though Hunter had kept telling himself he wasn't bi-curious, he found himself getting turned on by Kurt.

Soon, Kurt had a fun afternoon with Sebastian and Hunter, Kurt also had the time to hang out with his boys (Jeff, Trent, Nick, and Lucas), talking about his new job at Vogue, how life in New York is and how Kurt plans on making it to NYADA again, if the fashionista had another chance. By nightfall, Sebastian had a naughty plan and he whispered it to Hunter. "Hey, Hunt, whaddya say we take, our cute little twink to Dalton's pool and, do...a little skinny-dipping." Sebastian asked. Hunter smirked, he and Sebastian had been eyeing Kurt's body and also staring at Kurt's ass for a while. And, they've been wondering what Kurt looked like nude. They set their plan into motion when everyone began to turn in early.

"Hey Kurt, wanna go to the pool?" Sebastian asked. "Wait, this school has a pool?" The brunette diva asked. "Yes. And, since no one will bother us, what do you think, if you wanna join us, for a little...skinny-dipping? Hunter suggested. Kurt blushed at the thought of swimming naked with these two. But, what he had to lose, he was having a good time, so who was he to turn down an opportunity to have fun. "Alright, but I can't stay too long, cause chlorine does awful things for my skin." Kurt said. Hunter raised his eyebrow in confusion. "Apparently, Kurt likes to keep his skin nice and clean." Sebastian teased. Kurt smacked Sebastian on the hand who whined.

The three boys sneaked out to the Dalton pool and stripped down. This was the first time Kurt had seen Sebastian and Hunter naked, and honestly, they looked gorgeous! Sebastian was lanky, but nicely muscled, had nice smooth abs while Hunter was probably same but more built since Hunter went to military school. Sure they weren't as muscled or beefed as Puck or Sam, but, for Kurt, they were hot nonetheless. When Sebastian and Hunter laid eyes on Kurt, their jaws dropped. Kurt certainly had gained some muscles. Including some very nice smooth flat abs along that very flat but toned tummy. His skin was absolutely beautiful, pale and fair as porcelain, along with nice long legs and an ass that was nicely bubbly and pert, and the diva's package was nicely hung.

This, gave Kurt the opportunity to smirk at them and dive into the pool, the water splashing both Warblers. Making them splutter and stand in shock. "Hehe! Catch me if you can!" Kurt teased. The two smirked as they dove in after Kurt and chased him. The three had a fun playful time in the pool. Finally, Hunter and Sebastian managed to catch the sly little twink as Hunter held Kurt in a full-nelson while Sebastian tickled the divas chest and tummy, Kurt laughing and squealing his head off. But, as Kurt squirmed, Hunter gasped as he felt Kurt's perky ass rub against his dick, feeling it harden, and soon enough, Kurt felt Hunter's growing erection rub against his ass, making him blush deeply. Hunter then smirked as he rubbed his hands up and Kurt's body, "Hey Seb, what do you think we should do with this naughty boy?" Hunter asked as his hands tweaked and pinched Kurt's smooth, pink nipples making the countertenor squeak and blush, his nipples hardening at Hunters rough touch.

Sebastian, noticing Hunter toy with Kurt's body, smirked excitedly. The toying and playing turned him on. "I say we should punish him." Hunter walked to the other side of the pool and bent Kurt over, showing his ass to the two alpha males. "Think you can take a spanking, Princess?" Sebastian smirked. "Nnngh, I can take it." Kurt said, "Oh, let's prove it." Hunter said. Both taller boys raised their hands and began to roughly smack Kurt's ass. Sebastian taking Kurt's right cheek while Hunter spanked the left cheek. Kurt whined and mewled at each spank the two males gave him. And, felt his cock tingling at the painful pleasure. "Heh, sometimes punishment is too fun for you? Isn't it Kurt?" Hunter teased, nibbling at Kurt's neck.

Each spank lit Kurt's ass up until it was cherry red. That's when the three got out of the pool and Kurt moaned as Sebastian took his turn licking and sucking at Kurt's nipples while Hunter made out with Kurt. The two tongues battling each other for dominance until Hunter's tongue won the war and it slithered around in Kurt's mouth, thrusting the wet muscle in and out of Kurt's throat. Sebastian joined the kiss, now making it a three-way kiss. But, they pulled away and took a breather. "W-Wow, you guys are really great kissers." Kurt said, feeling dazed. "Kurt, I gotta admit something, when I heard about Blaine breaking up with you, I realized that he was too good for you and, you're now free. And, I realized that I actually wanted you for myself, but, if you want time to wait, I understand." Sebastian said. "No, Sebastian, I want you, and Hunter, now!" Kurt growled. "Heh, so bossy." Hunter gained, giving Kurt's tummy a kiss, his tongue swirling around Kurt's naval, making the boy whine. "So, Hunter, do you think you can give our little princess some head while I take his ass?" Sebastian suggested. "A-Actually, i want you both." Kurt said, "Huh?" Sebastian and Hunter asked. "I want you both, to fuck me, and I wanna ride you." Kurt said, blushing up a storm. The two Warblers smirked, "Alright, but first, lets get that ass of yours prepped." Hunter said. Both Hunter and Sebastian buried their faces into Kurt's ass. Covering it in their wet saliva. Their tongues thrusting in, and out of Kurt's ass. The diva's cock throbbing irritatingly and the boy a whimpering moaning mess. "G-Guys, you're gonna make me cum if you keep doing this....!" Kurt squealed. The two smirked and pulled their tongues out and sat together. With Sebastian in front of Hunter, their cocks fully hard, and leaking copious amounts of pre.

"You ready Kurt?" Sebastian asked. "N-no condoms?" Kurt asked. "Hell no. We're doing this...bareback." Hunter smirked, a wolfish grin on his face. Kurt blushed deeply, he slowly lowered himself, feeling his ass open up when both Hunter and Sebastian's cocks penetrated his ass. The boys all screaming in complete pleasure. Kurt took a little while to adjust to both Sebastian and Hunter's size, but took his time. He slowly began bouncing while Hunter held the counter-tenors chest and Sebastian smirked, gripping Kurt's cock, jerking it off while Kurt began to go faster. The sex was hot and heavy and it drove Kurt absolutely insane, he couldn't explain it, but somehow, Hunter and Sebastian brought out a more primal side to him as he bounced his ass on the Warblers cocks.

After a few more bounces, Hunter and Sebastian thrusted their dicks up into Kurt's ass. Hard, wet, loud lewd slaps of flesh against flesh echoing across the pool and air. The three boys were a hot mess as they sloppily made out with each other, sucking each others faces off while their tongues wrestled each other. Until Kurt pulled away Sebastian's mouth, "Oh my fucking Gaga I'm gonna cum!" Kurt moaned. "Oh you wanna cum huh?" Hunter taunted. "Y-yes!" Kurt squealed. "Then, cum for us babe." Sebastian teased, groping Kurt's cock, making Kurt scream snd unleash a hard torrent of cum. All over Sebastian's chest and belly, as well as Kurt's own belly, it wasn't long till both Hunter and Sebastian both cummed deep into Kurt. All three of them, breathing heavily as they laid down. "Oh....my......god....that was so fucking awesome..." Sebastian panted. "Y-Yeah....I think I'm starting to regret saying I'm not bi-curious...." Hunter moaned. "S-Sure you are." Sebastian and Kurt taunted. Soon the three all cleaned up, got redressed, slipped into Sebastian's dorm, since Kurt was now planning to stay the night. The three dressed into pajamas and snuggle up in a three-way spooning, all snuggled up in Sebastian's bed, falling asleep. Kurt had never felt any happier, now he has two hot-boyfriends to call his. He was so gonna boast to everyone and teach Blaine a lesson on how not to break someones heart.