YTFH 1: Plushie

Story by Myu Dalimo on SoFurry

, , , , , ,

A strange experience with stuffed animals.

This is part of an ongoing theme for this month with slots still available! Check here: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/38969377/

Join my Patreon now for discounts, voting on stuff, and skipping the commission queue line! https://www.patreon.com/mysterywolf

Read all kinds of other stories, and download them in other formats on https://mysterysden.com/


A man woke up to find he got a text alert on his phone. He unlocked the phone and checked the message.

'Juan: Your package has arrived, and is awaiting on your doorstep.'

"But it's Sunday?" Juan said to himself with a confused dry voice. He crawled out of bed. He walked up to the door and opened it up. He found a small package poorly placed in a bubble envelope. "Well, what do you know? It did arrive."

Juan was setting up everything for Christmas one day at a time, and it all started with a single present he got on the first day. He decided now was a good time to wrap it so he didn't have to deal with it later. He opened up the package and pulled out a yellow mouse plush. "Mom should love this." He gave the plush a squeeze and looked it over. As he glanced over the plush, he noticed another plush was in the bag. "Huh? I thought I just ordered one plush?"

Juan set the mouse aside and picked up the other plush. The plush creature looked like a brown horse with a white streak in the center. As he held it, he felt a bit strange. He scratched his rear and felt something want to push outwards. "Huh, weird." He mumbled to himself. "Well, I guess I'll give her two instead of the one." His rear continued to itch as he worked on wrapping both of the stuffed animals for his mother. Once he wrapped them up, he set them aside and scratched his rear. He couldn't explain it, but the itch continued to grow, and his pants began to prove to be a bother.

Juan pulled down his pants and underwear. He figured it was just his pants bugging him and decided to change out into another pair of underwear. He didn't think about putting some new pants back on, as he wasn't going outside. He slipped new underwear on, but it felt bizarrely tight behind him for a reason he couldn't explain. Should he look behind him, he would have seen the beginnings of a tail. "Ugh. Maybe I need to start exercising if these clothes are getting too tight for me." He said to himself with an annoyed tone.

Juan pulled down his underwear and got an idea. As he felt a strange sensation behind him, he decided to put his underwear on backwards instead. Unaware to him, his tail slipped through the hole in his underwear, and the strange sensation behind him vanished. "Perfect." He walked back to the living room happily. His short tail that grew black fur on it wagged to the left and right as it showed off his emotion. Just as Juan made it back to the living room, he noticed one of the stuffed animals was out from the present he wrapped it up earlier. The present didn't look as if someone opened it. The stuffed animal was just outside of it, as if he hadn't wrapped it at all.

"I swore I wrapped it up." Juan scratched his head with confusion. He grabbed the stuffed horse and looked it over. He felt a strange sensation as he held onto the plush, as if the plush had a strange power. "Hm." He tossed it onto the bed with a shrug. "Okay, fine. If you don't want to stay wrapped up, then you don't have to. I'll just give you to a charity or something tomorrow. Mom can have her original stuffed animal, and you can go to another home."

Juan spent the rest of his day as normal. He felt a weird sensation above his rear, but every time he looked and felt back to it, he didn't notice or feel anything bizarre. He thought if the issue didn't go away that he could just bring it up with his doctor, or just look it up online when people felt a strange feeling above their rear. He didn't feel any pain. He just felt an occasional whacking of something against his skin. 'You'd think something was different about me.' He thought to himself.

Later that night, he went to bed and rested on his side. Juan quickly fell asleep with a soft smile on his face.

Juan felt as if he awoke moments later, but his surroundings were different. He was in a bedroom with a variety of books and stuffed animals that he knew were not his. The bedroom would have resembled a child's with all the stuffed animals, but there was an equine anthro lying on the large bed in the center with a smile on her face. The horse was naked with a large equine cock. She grabbed Juan and pulled him in. "Well, I don't usually have fun with a stuffed animal like this, but I'm willing to try anything once." She said with a wicked tone.

Juan felt horrified. He couldn't move his body, but he felt his head turn towards a mirror. He stared at not himself, but a wolf plush creature with a stuffed cock and a dumb smile that he could not get rid of. He could only assume based on the equine's desire that he was one of 'those' kinds of stuffed animals, and that she was about to use him for their intended purpose.

Juan's eyes shot open back in his bed. He jumped up, and then turned his head. He noticed the stuffed horse on his bed, and he sighed. The stuffed horse looked exactly like the one in his sleep. 'Maybe my mind is just that perverted, or maybe there's more to this plush than meets the eye.' He thought to himself. He climbed out of bed and grabbed the plush. His short furry tail wagged behind him as he decided to toss the plush away into a container, and this time he locked the container so the plush surely couldn't escape.

'What a crazy dream. Imagine, having fun with a stuffed animal like that.' He thought to himself. He seemed oblivious to the tail that wagged behind him as he began his day anew.