Either Your God Hates Me Or Your Religion Doesn't Work
#41 of poetry
CW: Religion, Hostility to a category of religions in particular
I think I'm getting the hang of confessional essays in blank verse. I like the way it forces me to be concise.
If you are queer, and still hold to some faith
Of whatsoever christian sect, then I
Have no desire to undermine with doubt
What must remain a precious source of strength,
And must have been most difficult to keep.
So please do not regard what I must say
As aimed at you in any sense or way.
If you are straight and christian, then the work
Of grappling with this doubt is all on you.
I do not care what soul-dark nights you search.
I will not lift the first finger thereto.
I was taught, all my life, that God was love,
So loved the world He gave His Only Son,
Infinite, Inexhaustible, and pure.
I was told, also, that He hates me: not
Me in particular, for those who taught
This catechism knew not I was gay,
But that He hated those I could not help
But one day come to count myself among.
Of course there were a thousand actuallys.
I haven't searched them all, but I have searched
Enough of them to call them all dead ends.
They all boil down to: "God does not hate you
He only hates the part of you we hate!
He only hates whatever part of you
Without which you are not yourself! If you
Would only not be you, but someone else
Who we imagine that you should have been,
Why then, you would receive the love of God!"
But rationalizations are worth naught.
There's not a one of us who does not know
The contradiction cannot be sidestepped.
They claim God does not hate us. And they act
As if God hates us. What to do with that?
Perhaps God hates us. Very well, what then?
Why, very little. If God's as they say:
Omnipotent, Eternal, in control
Of all there is to all the universe
The same way that a writer weaves the ways
Of fate and freedom for his characters
Then what is there for us to do? We are
As fully foredoomed as would satisfy
The loftiest of Calvin's self-regards.
What purpose, then, to worship such a god?
No prayers will change that I am gay. I tried
For score and sixfold years. Nor no more will
The finite prayers of finite mortals weigh
For anything against infinite hate.
If I were God, and there were some I loathed
Why, prayers from them would likewise loathsome be.
A word of dear affection that from one
You love is sweet and precious, does turn rank
And vile when it is sent by one you hate.
So in this case, it would be for the best
To live as do the beasts that perish. Love
As long as I am able. And at last
Face God and walk me backward into hell.
Perhaps the contrary is true, and God
Does not hate us. What happens to the claim
That those who us have persecuted sore--
For there is no one point of christian thought
More durable, more unanimous than
Their phobia, it is the legacy
Their faith has left on world history--
Do love Him, that they His commandments keep?
Is not the point of christianity
That those who live it faithfully become
Like God? Like sons of God? What sons are these
Who hate what God their Father hateth not?
For if God does not hate us, then the faith
That follows Him seems plainly not to work.
What purpose, then, to keep to such a faith?
To congregate with those who, if they saw
My true face, would it excommunicate?
Far better, then, to strike out to the wilds
That they call 'hell,' by which they mean 'the place
That lies outside our walls, and must therefore
Be all the same, and nothing but torment'
And go whatever way I find me there.
So. On the one hand, deity quite deaf
To pleas for mercy that I shall not send.
And on the other, faith incompetant
To know the first thing of its deity.
Perhaps Divine Omniscience sees a way
Out of this contradiction. It may be.
If so, I beg He keep it to Himself.
It is long decades past the time when it
Ought to have been presented, when it could
Have still preserved efficacy of grace,
Have done my achilean soul some good.
I have my pagan gods. I have my place
Beside them in some afterworldly wood.
I have the faith I built me to embrace
My soul as is, not as it ought to be.
Go you your made-straight way. For I am free.