A Different Kind of Toy
A tiger meets his girlfriend's first ever lover, and while she isn't what he expected... he swiftly finds himself as charmed by her as his girlfriend is!
This story was written for Tygacat3891 as part of my patreon request days for November. It contains M/F sex between consenting adults, and intimate fun with a large stuffed animal. :3
A Different Kind of Toy
"Snowy, meet Jake. Jake, this is Snowy."
For a moment, Jake was confused. The tiger had been undeniably worried when his girlfriend asked him if he wanted to meet her first ever lover, but now that worry, that concern was melting away. Indeed after a few seconds even the confusion faded, and a smile spread over Jake's muzzle as he realised that this wasn't some set-up for a joke. He really was meeting his girlfriend's first ever lover.
Extending a warm, friendly hand in greeting, the tiger took hold of the right front paw of the huge, slightly play-worn stuffed polar bear sitting upon the middle of Katie's bed and shook it gently.
"Pleased to meet you, Snowy."
Turning his head towards his girlfriend, the skunk standing close by with a joyous smile of her own spread across her face as she watched her boyfriend introduce himself, Jake chuckled at the sincere joy obvious to behold in Katie's eyes. Despite the skunk being almost a decade older than the thirty year old tiger, she had always had a playfulness about her. An eager, exuberant energy that was infectious in the most wonderful way. Before meeting her, Jake had always looked for relationships with older women because he believed that maturity, someone with a sensible head on their shoulders was what he craved most from a long term partner. Now though, he understood that maturity was relative. That one's ability to have fun when the time allowed it bore little relation to their ability to manage their life, to pay the bills on time, to hold a steady job, and to give themselves the free time and ability to cast off those more mature activities and simply have fun.
And as he watched Katie begin to disrobe, starting to take off her clothes without any prior suggestion that she might intend to do so, Jake could only imagine what kind of fun she had planned for them today.
"Snowy's been with me forever. Through every relationship I've had, she's always been there. B-but... I've never actually told any of my other lovers about her. Not one, u-until you, Jake."
The tiger's cheeks flushed, half due to the now naked skunk sliding her panties down to her ankles and kicking them aside before beginning to scramble up onto the bed, half because of her admission and the clear meaning behind that fact. Two days ago Jake had asked Katie if she might consider moving in with him, and at the time he had been aghast and embarrassed when she said that she had to think about it. But, if she was telling him this, if she was entrusting him with what sounded like an immensely personal, private secret such as this...
Giggling bashfully, the naked skunk crawled over her bed and into the arms of the stuffed toy polar bear whose hand Jake had still been absent-mindedly holding till just moments before. A polar bear whose body while more cartoonily proportioned matched both his and Katie's own in size, and who quite clearly didn't live tucked away in the corner of the room where Jake had always seen it resting when he came over to hang out or spend the night in the past. He watched as Katie cuddled up against the plush toy, not just cosily, but intimately. He watched as she giggled, slowly pushing the huge stuffed animal over into its back... onto her back, if he'd heard Katie address the polar bear correctly earlier. And he watched as sure enough Snowy tumbled over backwards, and Katie tumbled with her, the skunk's rump and lush tail soon waving in the air as her legs wrapped around the stuffed toy's waist, and a soft yet ragged moan escaping Katie's lips as her crotch pressed to the soft, plush fur of the polar bear and began to gently rock against Snowy's comfy, cushioned mass.
"Tell me what you're thinking."
Blinking, blushing as he realised that he was just staring at Katie as she rocked her hips and casually, gently masturbated herself against the stuffed animal, Jake glanced around as though nervous that what he was thinking might be overheard. Sure enough though they were alone in the bedroom, alone in Katie's large apartment. Just the two of them, or, perhaps just the three of them if indeed Snowy was included as she currently seemed to be. He looked back at the bed, back to his lover's beautiful backside and her face, head craning back over one shoulder, smiling hopefully, longingly at him.
"I think that... t-that Snowy means a lot to you. That maybe a part of why you didn't say yes when I asked if we could live together, is because you worry that living with me might mean giving up Snowy, and what you... what the two of you share."
The skunk whimpered nervously, her smile fading a little and her head turning away from Jake, burying her face in the soft white fur of the polar bear's neck and tightening her grip around Snowy's upper body. Her squeezing compressed the toy's stuffed innards in a way that made its body fold and tilt, Snowy's head seeming to peer up and over Katie's shoulder, two black glass eyes regarding Jake with unblinking focus. Even though it was just the toy watching him, not Katie, he still shook his head as he smiled reassuringly.
"It's okay, Katie. I... god, I'd never make you give up something you love."
He saw how tightly she was holding onto the stuffed animal. How her body trembled, how even now she was almost uncontrollably grinding her crotch up against Snowy's fur for comfort, as well as for pleasure. Jake sighed.
"And, I sure as hell wouldn't ask you to give up some_one_ who means so much to you. I can't say I've ever thought much about this. I can't say I've ever imagined something like this happening. But... even though god knows you don't need my permission, or my approval, for this or for anything... I still want to move in with you, knowing this. Seeing this. I still want to have you... and Snowy move in with me as much as ever. More, actually. Because now there's just one more thing I know about you that I'm absolutely in love with."
For a few moments silence fell over the room, Jake watching, blushing, very aware of the lack of an immediate response from Katie and at the same time the swollen erection straining at the front of his jeans. Then he heard a soft, muffled giggle from his girlfriend, and watched as Katie's face pulled back from the polar bear's neck only for the skunk's plump figure to scoot its way just a little further up Snowy's own rounded form, moving as though attempting to whisper in the stuffed animal's ear. And indeed whisper she did, though in the vocal sort of stage-whisper that ensured Jake could not only hear her, but do so knowing that he was meant to hear each and every word.
"See, Snowy? I told you he would understand."
She turned her head, beaming at Jake and grinning as he blushed and beamed right back. But rather than keeping her whole attention focused on the tiger for now, it wasn't long until Katie's eyes widened, and she rather swiftly pressed one of her own ears to the protruding muzzle of the polar bear beneath her. Her eyes closed for a moment in concentration, and her already dazzling grin grew even more so while she squirmed and giggled once again.
"O-oh... oh Snowy, you're such a naughty girl."
When she raised her head again, when she turned her neck and looked right at Jake, Katie's eyes were wide open and yet heavy, laden with deep, seductive passion that poured from her gaze like molten treacle. She flushed crimson beneath her fur, and her hips continued to rock, squirm and grind against the stuffed animal between her legs as she spoke not for herself, but on the polar bear's behalf.
"S-Snowy says... she thinks I'd be really happy moving in with you. She thinks she'd be happy too. But... there's just one thing that she wants to know first."
Katie rolled off of Snowy, curling up against the side of the polar bear but leaving the huge stuffed animal's body exposed, a small, damp patch of slightly matted fur resting where the skunk's nether regions had been pressed just moments before. With one hand Katie reached down between her own legs, moaning with breathy desire as she slipped two fingers between the already flushed, swollen lips of her nether regions. And with the other, she reached down between Snowy's legs, tenderly, intimately stroking at the wet spot upon the polar bear's white fur as though it was born of the stuffed animal's own desire. She looked up at Jake, and giggled gleefully as she saw the tiger watching her... watching them tease and play in front of him, and spoke for Snowy once more.
"She wants proof that you can satisfy a woman like me. Proof that if we move in together, she'll know that even on days when I'm not with her, I'm still more than satisfied by my other lover. By you."
Jake grinned, needing no further coaxing and immediately beginning to peel off his clothing. Soon he was naked, his cock flexing and twitching before both Katie and Snowy's gaze as he stood for a moment, letting them observe his visible, eager desire for them before scrambling up to join the two women upon the bed itself. He crawled up to them and knelt just by their feet, groaning happily as Katie rolled away from Snowy and spread her own legs out much as the polar bear's lower limbs were spread. The skunk's lush tail twitched happily from side to side as she rubbed slow circles over her clitoris, eyes heavy, buxom chest rising and falling rather rapidly, and all the while she mimicked the same motions upon Snowy's own soft, motionless body.
"Snowy... you want me to prove I can satisfy Katie? T-that I won't rest, that I won't relax until any woman I care for is satisfied?"
The polar bear didn't answer as Jake tenderly growled his question, but on her behalf Katie let loose a ragged, happy moan.
"Oohhh... yes..."
Grinning, the tiger licked his lips and shuffled a little further forward. Katie spread her legs wider, and stopped rubbing her clit as she used the fingers of that same hand to part the lips of her pussy, showing off the flushed, wet interior of her nether regions to Jake in an obvious, shameless act of temptation.
"You want to see... to feel how dedicated I can be to the woman I love? You want to feel it, right now? Right here?"
Again he growled, and again Katie let loose a longing, gleeful wail of affirmation.
"Aaahhhyes. Yes, J-Jake... please. Please. Now!"
Jake grinned at his lust-stricken, uncontrollably horny girlfriend. At the skunk he utterly adored, and the adorable, huge stuffed animal next to her whom she was still absent-mindedly fondling, pleasuring with her free hand. He knew what Katie wanted. He knew she wanted him to pounce upon her in that moment, to fuck her, to ravage her, and to let her cry out her ecstasy to Snowy, proving once and for all that Jake was the man for her, a man of whom even Snowy herself wouldn't be able to help but approve.
But, he also knew the kind of woman Katie was beyond her horniness. He knew the playful, fun-loving creature she always loved to be, and he knew just how much she loved it when he was even a fraction as playful and light-hearted as her, though it didn't come nearly so naturally to Jake as it did to the skunk. And thus, he knew... or at least he hoped with all his heart, that what he actually had planned would delight Katie even more than if he'd given her every last drop of the passion and pleasure burning inside him in that moment.
"Let's show her what I'll always be ready, always be eager to share."
The tiger growled tenderly, glancing from Katie to the polar bear, then back to the skunk, then back to Snowy once more. Again Katie gurgled. Again the desperate, feverishly horny skunk whimpered and nodded with pleading glee as she continued to spread her lips wide open in anticipation of Jake's cock plunging between them. And then...
"Let's show Katie just how much I want to make her happy, Snowy."
Jake teasingly murmured as his gaze shifted from the skunk to the polar bear one last time, settling upon Snowy as he moaned her name. Then he lunged forward, flung himself down over the huge stuffed animal's soft, plush, warm body, and as a frantic shriek of shock, of wonder, and of pure lust erupted from Katie right beside them, he began to hump the polar bear with the same passion, the same adoration, and the same complete, focused devotion that he would have given to Katie.
"Jake! S-Snowy?! Oh my god. O-oohh my god, he's... Snowy, he's fucking you!"
With a passionate, gleeful snarl, Jake glanced to his left and saw Katie's eyes bulging as she watched him do exactly what she'd just screamed, watching him buck and thrust against the stuffed animal's soft, surprisingly pleasurable form, as close to truly fucking Snowy as he conceivably could. He saw his lover's mind reeling with the unexpected and overwhelmed, overjoyed shock of what she was seeing, and just a few seconds later he saw her head throw itself back in a wail of fresh elation as the fingers prising her pussy wide open in expectation of Jake's cock suddenly found themselves driving desperately, urgently in and out of those wet, clutching depths in place of the otherwise occupied tiger.
Pumping his hips down against the stuffed animal, feeling her soft-filled interior compress beneath his weight only to spring back up and maintain a delicious pressure against his member even when he pulled back, Jake couldn't help but instinctively glance down at Snowy between longer, more lustful looks towards his wide eyed and now furiously masturbating girlfriend. Every time he looked at Snowy with passion in his eyes he swore he heard a louder cry than normal escape Katie as she rapidly finger-fucked herself in time with the tiger's thrusts, thus it didn't take Jake long to begin paying yet more and more attention to the stuffed toy. He leaned down and nuzzled against Snowy, nose to nose just like he did with Katie when they made love. He pecked at the sides of her muzzle with fond, frantic flurries of kisses, and nibbled on her neck with deep, instinctive growls.
The more he made the motions of stimulating Snowy, the more viscerally and overwhelmingly Katie's own body reacted, almost more strongly than if he was doing those actions upon the skunk directly in some cases. And when he began to speak, to whisper secretively to Snowy in the same faux-subtle manner that Katie had whispered to the polar bear herself, the ear-splitting shriek of lustful rapture that Katie let loose was undeniably beyond any sound of pleasure that Jake had ever been given cause to draw forth from the skunk when they were alone together.
"D-do you want me to cum in you, Snowy? Or... should I save myself, my cum, for my girlfriend?"
Mere seconds later, Katie descended into an ever more maddened frenzy of loud, unabashedly intense masturbation with fingers loudly slurping in and out of herself, with her pussy gushing as she struck her g-spot over and over again and with her muzzle hanging wide open in a near constant stream of babbling, blissful profanity. She watched Snowy and Jake fucking through wide, glazed eyes, and continued to do so as the tiger pressed one ear to Snowy's motionless muzzle, listened for a short while even as he continued to hump the stuffed animal, then pulled himself back from the polar bear. He grinned down at both Snowy and the skunk, Katie still trembling, still urgently pleasuring herself close by, and nodded to the polar bear as he licked his lips.
"I think you're right. And... I think she'll like that too."
Katie practically wailed as she stared back and forth between the tiger and the polar bear, desperate to learn the secret they'd shared.
"W-what?! What will I like? O-oh please... please, Snowy... tell me..."
She lunged towards the other woman, flinging herself over Snowy's now available body once again while still continuing to pleasure herself with one hand, embracing the plush polar bear tightly with her free arm and pressing her ear immediately to Snowy's maw. It was her other ear that soon heard a soft, slightly higher pitched voice whispering into it though, Jake taking a calculated leap and rather than simply speaking on Snowy's behalf, speaking as Snowy for what he hoped would be Katie's benefit.
"I told Jake... he should fuck you. He should cum in you. B-but, that you should hold me, just like you already are, w-while he does it. So I can feel it. So I can feel how good he makes you feel. And so we're both sure that when you cum for us... just like we've both felt you do so many times before, you can feel us both there with you. So you know how loved you are, and so you know that whether you move in with Jake or not right now, we're both still gonna be here for you. W-we're both always... always going to be here for you, Katie."
Before Katie could do more than whimper happily and plant a deep, surprisingly erotic kiss upon the polar bear's plush muzzle in the wake of Snowy's whispered words, she felt a hand upon the wrist of her feverishly masturbating paw. She felt Jake pulling her fingers free from her clutching, dripping depths, and shrieked in a mixture of excitement and desperation as he pressed that dripping wet paw to Snowy's crotch, whispering in his own voice now as he shuffled into place behind the skunk and leaned down over her.
"She's so close. You can feel it, right? H-how near she is. How ready. Use your fingers. Make her scream."
Then, without another moment's hesitation, Katie felt the tiger's cock pressing inside of her. She felt his arms wrapping around her from above, and she felt waves of fresh, even more intense pleasure bursting and boiling within her as she stared down, panting and wailing anew, into the unmoving, happily smiling face of Snowy.
"Cum with us, Katie."
Jake moaned as he fucked his girlfriend, already so close after just how good it had felt, how hot it had been watching her pleasure herself as he humped the polar bear.
"Ahh... aaahhh, Katie. Snowy. I... I'm right there. I'm gonna... oh god, please. Please, l-ladies... cum with me."
He gasped and panted, he begged shamelessly to both women; flesh and blood, stitches and stuffing, his passion equal and sincere regardless. And to his delight just moments later, as his cock throbbed, as his balls tightened and as he began to empty himself out into Katie amidst yowling cries of his own savage pleasure, he heard Katie crying out in answer not just for herself as she shrieked in orgasm, but on behalf of both herself and Snowy.
"Ohh Jake! O-oooohhhh god, I... I'm... we're... oh, yes! Jake, Snowy, s-she's... and, I... aahh yes. Yes! We're... _aahhhhh yes _! We're cumming!"
By Jeeves
Like my stories? Want access to a whole host of writing weeks or even months before it appears on other sites as well as exclusive request days to get stuff written for yourself? Consider supporting me on patreon with rewards from as low as $5 per month! https://www.patreon.com/jeevesroo :D