An Unexpected Crush

Story by ComfortableCreatures on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Commissioned by

@ProwlingJinouga

A human guy finds himself crushing on a gorgeous leopard at the pool that he mistakenly thinks is a woman. What follows is a very rapid discovery of his own sexuality.


Jake liked coming to the pool late, he was fortunate that the public pool was open until midnight. On weekdays, it was pretty much deserted for the three hours or so before it closed. A perfect time to get a workout in. Tonight however, he wasn't alone, there was another swimmer who seemed to have the same idea.

She was a leopard, her black one-piece swimsuit hugged her curves tightly and could barely contain that perfect bubble butt of hers. Jake was smitten immediately, he always had a thing for anthros despite growing up in a city that was ninety percent human. He remembered getting teased by a few kids in school when he had posters of anthro super models on his wall. None of them compared to the beauty before him now though.

He wondered if he should swim out to her, try to spark up a conversation, perhaps when she stopped to rest. But he doubted someone swimming so late at night wanted to be bothered and besides… he had another problem to deal with, raging erection in his swim trunks. If he tried to talk to her like this he would just get a slap in the face and probably be banned from the pool if she complained. Instead, he decided to cut his workout short and head for the locker room.

Even the cold water from the shower as he rinsed the chlorine off of himself failed to quell his lust, his mind unable to think of anything else but that bombshell of a leopard. Biting his lower lip, Jake realized he was going to need to deal with this. He was the only guy in the pool right now, so he would have enough privacy to quickly crank one out, but on the off chance someone came in off the street, the attached sauna would offer a much more secluded space to do his business. As an added bonus, the warm space would be much more comfortable than the cold showers. With his decision made, he stepped into the sauna.

There, he sat down on the bench, poured some water on the coals to get some steam going and began to get to the task at hand. Hand gripping his meat, he began stroking himself vigorously while daydreaming of the absolute babe he had the privilege to see earlier.

Jake was losing himself in his own little world and he was well on his way to a happy ending when he heard the showers in the other room. Heart racing, Jake stopped, covering himself as he waited, staring at the sauna door. Who the hell could be using the shower at this hour? How did they even get in? The door from the outside was heavy and made quite the loud 'thunk' when it was pushed open. There wasn't a door separating the changing rooms from the pool, just a short hallway with a bend so you couldn't see inside from the pool area, but there weren't any other men out there!

He didn't have to wait long to find out the answer to this mystery, as the door to the sauna swung open, the leopard stepping inside. Jake was shocked, first at the fact that a woman was in the men's locker room, completely nude! Second, at the sudden and stunning realization that his dream “woman" was not a woman at all. Without the swim suit, Jake could see clearly the complete absence of breasts, not even mosquito bites and the rather thick cock swinging between the leopard's legs.

Jake was straight, he was sure of that and yet, despite that, the revelation he had been jacking it to a dude and the sight of that very same and very naked man didn't immediately kill his boner. No, in fact, he was just as hard as ever.

The leopard sat down just a few feet from Jake, making the task of hiding his erection all the more difficult.

“Nice night for a swim, isn't it?" he said, in a voice that if Jake had been blindfolded, he doubted he could have correctly identified whether it belonged to a man or a woman.

“Uh… y-yeah. I suppose it is." Jake said, blushing as he stumbled over his words. He was flustered like he was talking to a schoolyard crush! But this was just a dude! A dude with a… amazing hourglass figure, as well as long, perfect legs, a round cushioned ass, a cute androgynous face with a kissable muzzle, fur that looked so soft and a big, thick coJake caught himself as his eyes drifted down, locking onto that cock, before immediately shooting back up to meet the leopard's eyes. Never in his life had he checked out another man's cock, he always avoided looking below the belt, he should have felt disgust at the sight not… whatever he just felt. A wave of embarrassment washed over him, he hoped the leopard didn't notice his indiscretion… and hoped the sauna's heat hid the redness of his skin from his deep blushing.

“Do you swim at night often?" the feline asked, unfazed.

“Oh… um, most of the time I do, yeah." Jake admitted.

The leopard smiled. “That's great! I'm totally the same, I just moved to this town and don't know many people so it's awesome to meet a fellow night swimmer. I'm Ash by the way, most people just call me Ashley though." Of course his name is androgynous too. “I'm Jake." Jake muttered out.

“So, Jake…" Ashley leaned closer to the human, a smile spreading across his muzzle. “How about we skip the flirting and just fuck?" Jake's eyes went wide, he nearly fell off the bench in shock. He stammered and struggled to form words for several moments, before finally mustering a pathetic “What?" The leopard grabbed his wrist, pulling it away from his lap. “You can't hide this monster from me. Plus, did you really think I didn't notice those wandering eyes of yours? I've never seen someone down quite as bad as you are. But that's okay, I think you're pretty cute too." he teased.

Jake's heart was racing, he couldn't quite believe this was happening. But this wasn't right! He wasn't “down bad" for another guy! He was straight!

“I… err, I don't. I mean… I'm not…" Jake stammered and stuttered, unable to find his words.

Ashley stopped him. “Shhh, don't worry. We won't do anything you aren't comfortable with. You just say stop and I will stop, one simple word, okay?" Jake nodded. One simple word, even in his flustered and panicked state, he could manage that. But then… why couldn't he? He opened his mouth to say it, put a stop to it before things went too far, but he couldn't bring himself to say it.

His silence became consent, as Ashley wrapped his hand around the base of Jake's cock and slowly began stroking it. The soft fur on his hands, the even softer pads on the tips of his fingers and the feline's obvious skill at the task made a simple handjob feel absolutely heavenly. Jake threw his head back and groaned, he couldn't help it.

“You're so big…" Ashley teased. “I can barely fit my hand around it."

His words gave Jake a rush of pride.

Jake looked back down, as even in the heat of the sauna, he could feel the soft breeze and warmth from the leopard's breath on his shaft. His muzzle was only a scant few inches away as he had leaned over. Jake could almost just pretend that Ashley was a girl from this perspective.

“It looks so tasty too…" Ashley said, his words intermixed with a dreamy sigh. He then closed those last couple of inches, starting at Jake's balls, running his tongue along his fleshy sack, before sliding further up his shaft.

Jake moaned out, man or not, this felt amazing.

The human then felt a tugging at his wrist, Ashley guiding Jake's hand right into the leopard's lap. Jake instinctively tensed up as he felt his fingers brushing against another man's erection. So much for pretending he was with a girl right now… There was a brief pause where Ashley stopped moving, like he was waiting for Jake to say something. But he still couldn't do it, so Ashley just giggled and resumed running his tongue over Jake's cock.

It wasn't long before the feline took the tip of Jake's member into his mouth. Running his tongue in circles around the head had the human trembling and moaning where he sat. With his hand still brushing against Ashley's member, it took Jake a moment to notice that the feline wasn't even holding him there anymore. Feeling awkward, he knew it would be rude to pull away, the leopard was currently sucking his dick and… fair was fair, right? If Jake was going to let things go this far, he shouldn't be the only one getting off.

Besides… it was just a little touching… that didn't automatically make him gay or anything…

Jake's fingers wrapped around the feline's cock. Everyone always assumes little effeminate guys have tiny cocks, but Ashley's was anything but! He was easily just as large as Jake, with Jake having similar trouble fitting his fingers around the shaft. As Ashley began taking Jake deeper into his maw and, eventually, throat, Jake began slowly moving his hand up and down the feline's length. He was clumsy, nervous and only had experience handling his own dick, never someone else's. But, Ashley didn't seem to mind, letting out soft little moans that reverberated around Jake's member, like rewards for his effort.

As the leopard managed to take all of him, a feat his previous girlfriend couldn't manage, Jake knew he wasn't going to be able to last long. It only took the feline bobbing his head a few more times, before Jake groaned out and came right into his mouth.

Ashley didn't complain, he seemed delighted to receive the human's load, drinking it down and not pulling away until he had tasted every drop. When he did pull away, he had a satisfied smile on his face, perhaps even prideful of his ability to make Jake bust so soon… Jake meanwhile was catching his breath, but that didn't last long before he felt a hand on the back of his head pulling him down… Jake didn't resist, he was caught off guard! He was still recovering from his orgasm! Whatever excuse he wanted to mentally assign to why he let this happen, the fact was that Jake now found himself with his nose pressed into the fur just above the feline's cock. From here, a lot of his mental pretenses began to break down, anything he did now he couldn't blame on the leopard's girly appearance.

From here all he could see of the feline was his penis. His man meat, his dong, his cock, his schlong, his dick. The smell too, there were some background notes of some fruity shampoo he may have used at one point, but that was far overwhelmed by the smell of natural musk and ball sweat, which were unmistakably masculine.

“Lick it." Ashley instructed. His words weren't firm or commanding, just a suggestion on what Jake should do next.

By all accounts, Jake should be screaming stop, he should be utterly disgusted by where he was. He wasn't into guys!

But he obeyed. Running his tongue along the shaft.

Maybe this was just a one time thing… plenty of guys experiment at one point. Fair was fair after all… it didn't mean anything.

But if it didn't mean anything… why did he find himself enjoying the taste? It was the taste of flesh, sweat and musk. Jake should be gagging right now but it was oddly enjoyable. As he reached the tip, his tongue was greeted with a bead of sweet tasting pre-cum.

Ashley's hand, still on the back of Jake's head, pushed down, pressing his cock tip firmly against the human's lips. It slid right inside, the supposedly straight human putting up no resistance and opening his mouth at the slightest provocation.

With Ashley's hand gently nudging him, Jake began bobbing his head along the leopard's length, until eventually he didn't need Ashley's guidance for the task.

Ashley began to moan gently. “Mmf, your mouth feels amazing… and that tongue! Such an eager slut. You love the taste of my cock, don't you?" Those words should have been emasculating to Jake, but he felt pride at the pleasure he was causing the feline to experience, especially as a first-timer! He hadn't even realized how active his tongue was, as he eagerly wanted to taste every inch of the feline's member. He couldn't deny anything Ashley said, he was already rock hard again, more turned on now than he had been before. He couldn't lie, not even to himself.

He was loving every second of this.

“Mm-hmm." Jake groaned as his heterosexuality was starting to crumble to dust.

Ashley began guiding him again, this time pushing him to take the leopard deeper. He was slow and gentle about it, not pushing Jake beyond what he could take. The inexperienced human had never done something like this and it took some coaching from the much more experienced feline… but they both found Jake was a quick study when he was motivated.

Soon enough he managed to take the leopard's girth into his throat without gagging or coughing. It was a tight fit, but each time he came back up for air, he was able to take Ashley's shaft a little deeper. A few more attempts and Jake felt fur brushing against his nose. He had done it, he had the whole thing inside his throat!

“F-fuck… I've always wanted to be deepthroated by a human, your mouths are so shallow… so much of my cock is in your throat." Ashley groaned. His dick throbbed and twitched, it was clear he was enjoying himself quite a bit.

Jake began to bob his head along the leopard's full length, sometimes pausing for a few moments when he bottomed out, letting the feline bask in the feeling of the human's constricting throat. Ashley didn't even have his hand on Jake's head anymore, his hands bracing on the bench as he leaned back, moaning loudly.

“I'm gonna cum!" Ashley exclaimed.

Jake didn't even hesitate, it was like his body was acting on its own. He pulled back until only the tip of Ashley's cock was still in his mouth, stroking the shaft rapidly until the leopard let out a growl, his cock twitched and white, sticky, hot cum flooded Jake's mouth.

It was sweet, salty and a little bitter all in one with a slimy texture. Jake was drinking it down like it was the nectar of the gods. He couldn't get enough of it! He really was turning into a cum slut.

“Holy shit… that was amazing." Ashley sighed, his body relaxing as Jake swallowed the last of it down.

The human pulled away and began to sit up, feeling lightheaded as realized he might have gotten a little overzealous while deepthroating the feline.

Suddenly, Ashley leaned in, pressing his muzzle to Jake's lips. A passionate kiss ensued, both men's tongues eagerly exploring the other's maw, both their mouths still carrying the taste of cum on their breath.

When it finally broke and Ashley slowly pulled away, he took notice of Jake's erection. “How about we take this back to a nice, soft bed at my place, hot stuff?" he asked in a teasing manner, running a single finger along the human's length while flashing him a seductive smirk.

Jake nodded, it still felt weird to him, agreeing to accompany another man home for sex. But, he was enjoying himself far too much to say no and he was still completely smitten by the leopard.

The pair got up and made their way out of the sauna, hurriedly getting dressed in the locker room while they waited for their rideshare to get there.

Ashley's street clothes did nothing to hide his incredibly effeminate form. His jean shorts barely clung to his ass and showed off his incredible legs clad in a pair of white thigh high socks. In addition, his tight-fitting pink tank-top accentuated his vaguely hourglass figure; so in all he certainly stood out next to the more plainly dressed human in jeans and a t-shirt, but nobody could claim he wasn't proud of his girly figure.

When they got into the back of the car together, Jake was still flustered, as though he was on a first date with the girl of his dreams. Though, he supposed, that analogy wasn't too far off the mark… Thankfully, Ashley immediately hit it off with the driver by commenting on their music choices, a conversation he was able to effortlessly carry the entire ride over to his apartment. As a result, Jake didn't have to worry about coming across too awkwardly, at least not until they got into the apartment complex elevator where he found himself alone with the leopard once again.

The leopard however seemed to have things other than small talk on his mind as he pinned Jake to the wall, the human taken off guard and breathing heavily as the feline assaulted him with a barrage of kisses to his lips and neck.

The leopard then leaned in, whispering right into Jake's ear. “I hope you don't mind bottoming tonight…" he growled. “I've always wanted to take a 'straight' boy's virginity." Jake was stunned, more by Ashley claiming to somehow know that he was, at least formerly, straight than he was by the prospect that he would be taking it up the ass. Though that still weighed at least somewhat heavily on his mind.

“Don't worry, I'll be gentle. It will feel amazing." the leopard reassured him when Jake didn't say anything.

Jake slowly nodded, every experience he has had with the leopard so far has been amazing in life-changing ways. Despite never wanting so much as a finger up there before, he believed Ashley and was actually a little… excited?

As the elevator doors opened, Ashley practically jogged up to his door, quickly unlocking it and pulling Jake inside. Once the door was shut, it was a flurry of kissing, groping and stripping one-another of their clothing. Neither man could keep their hands off the other and a trail of discarded clothes left a breadcrumb trail straight to Ashley's bedroom door.

If Jake had the capacity to pay attention to anything other than the leopard, he would notice that the feline's claim to having only just moved in checked out. Walls and shelves were barren and there was only the bare minimum of furniture, likely what came with the apartment.

Ashley pushed Jake down onto the bed, soft and brand new, this was likely to be the first “action" the bed was about to see, but definitely not the last. Pushing Jake onto all fours, the human moaned out as he felt the feline's muzzle slip between his cheeks, Ashley eagerly eating his ass out, lubricating his virgin hole with his tongue.

Jake couldn't deny it felt weird. But good.

The leopard opened the nightstand drawer, pulling out a bottle of lube. He drizzled some of it onto his cock, using his hand to rub it on and more evenly coat his shaft. Jake knew it was almost time for the main event… “Just relax, don't tense up." Ashley said in a gentle voice, as he began pressing two lube-covered fingers against the human's tight back door.

Tense is exactly what Jake should be, even if he had discovered his sexuality sooner anyone would be nervous their first time! But he wasn't, the leopard's presence and comforting words were soothing. It was like his body just knew that as long as he listened to Ashley, everything would be fine.

Ashley slid the pair of fingers inside, slowly pushing them as deep as he could, wriggling them around and sliding them in and out for a few moments. It felt odd, but not unpleasant in the slightest.

“Good boy." He cooed.

Jake's cock twitched, leaking pre onto Ashley's sheets… those words had a bigger effect than he would have expected.

The tip of Ashley's cock was pressed against his virgin hole. Slowly and gently, it was pushed inside, the leopard taking the human's virginity inch after inch.

“Holy shit… straight ass feels amazing." the leopard groaned.

“I-I don't think I can be called straight anymore…" Jake panted out, his voice shaky and struggling to form words as his asshole was spread wide open. It hurt a little, but Ashley was careful and very good at reading Jake's body language, never pushing him beyond what he was ready for.

Ashley chuckled. “Nah, it's not gay until your boyfriend is the one fucking you."

“Is that an- mmf- o-offer?" Jake asked, the previously tongue-tied male strangely more at ease and able to find his voice now that there was a dick working its way up his ass.

“Do you want it to be?" Ashley asked.

Jake nodded. “Yes." he said, without any hesitation.

“Then I guess you really are gay now." Ashley teased, as his hips finally made contact with Jake's ass, his cock balls deep inside the human.

“J-just like that?" he asked, in between grunts and groans, surprised and sounding out of breath. He couldn't believe just how full he felt.

“Yeah, you'll find I'm a pretty laid back guy." he said, slowly rocking his hips back and forth in short, gentle thrusts as Jake got used to his full girth. “Besides, you're a damn good lay and I get the feeling you might actually be able to keep up with my libido. I'm a pretty needy boyfriend who needs lots and lots of attention." the leopard explained, moaning softly.

Given how Jake couldn't seem to control his libido either in the presence of the leopard, Ashley's high sex drive was certainly not going to deter him one bit. Jake's groans were soon replaced entirely with moans of pleasure, he never imagined anal would feel so good! Was it just his obsession with the leopard currently fucking him fueling this, or was he really such a butt slut deep down?

It didn't really matter, all that did matter was that Jake wanted more.

“Harder." he moaned out through gritted teeth. “Fuck me harder."

This definitely got the leopard's attention as he let out an amused growl. But, instead of complying with the human's request, he suddenly pulled his entire length out.

“Why did you stop?" Jake whimpered pathetically as he was left feeling so very empty.

“Patience." the leopard said, but Jake didn't have much of that, he needed Ashley's cock back inside of him!

Ashley flipped the human over onto his back, hooking his hands behind Jake's knees as he lifted up his legs.

“Much better, now I can look you in the eyes." the leopard said, doing just that with a gentle smile.

Jake stared right back, losing himself in the leopard's golden eyes.

“Beg." Ashley growled.

“P-please… fuck me." Jake whimpered needily.

“Fuck you where?" Ashley growled again, an intensity behind his eyes.

“Please, fuck my ass." Jake elaborated.

A big grin spread over Ashley's muzzle. He lined his cock back up to the human's rear entrance and with a single thrust, found himself buried within him again.

While still careful not to push the inexperienced male too far, Ashley was not as gentle this time, already pistoning his hips, driving his cock in and out of the other male's hole.

Jake was a squirming, moaning mess. He did his best not to close his eyes, wanting to watch as the man of his dreams, dreams he never knew he had, ravaged him. Watching the expression on his face as he began actually putting some effort behind those thrusts.

Ashley leaned in, pressing his muzzle to Jake's lips without warning. Entangled in a intense, feverish kiss while having his ass roughly fucked, it was too much for Jake.

He came, shooting thick sticky ropes of cum all over both of their chests, his first ever orgasm achieved without anything actually touching his cock.

Ashley's cock meanwhile was throbbing, pulsing. The leopard broke the kiss and confirmed what Jake suspected.

“I'm gonna cum… tell me where you want it." he said, sounding out of breath.

“Outside! I want to be covered in your cum!" Jake yelled out.

The leopard didn't say anything, just a growl turning to a roar as he pulled his cock out from Jake's ass. He didn't grab it in time to aim the first shot, going wild and splattering Jake right in the face. The following shots of jizz were more controlled, painting Jake's chest and stomach white with a mixture of his own and the leopard's seed.

Soon, the leopard was left panting, admiring his own handiwork with a lustful grin.

Jake just lied there, in utter bliss, his body covered in his boyfriend's virility. A few hours ago he would never have expected to end up in this position, but now, he couldn't think of anywhere he would rather be.