Debt

Story by Picklessauce69 on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

#8 of LusterUnicorn's Monthly Commission Subscription

December's LusterUnicorn monthly story! Here it is! This time, using just a touch of monthly seasonal inspiration, I sorta just let the story go where it wetnnt and I just followed along. I hope it turns out as good as I thought it did! Hah! As always, enjoy both the porn and the holiday vibes :)


Knock, Knock, Knock.

Knock, Knock, Knock.

Luster groaned, hearing a distant pounding echoing through his apartment. He just whined, as though trying to dismiss it as he grabbed for his pillow and folded it over his small, floppy ears.

Knock, Knock, Knock.

The sound just came again, not listening to his silent demands that he wanted to keep sleeping even as late morning sun streamed in through the break in his curtains. "God..." he whined, voice rough with the lingering grogginess of sleep. "Who is it this early?"

Mentally, he traveled back in time to the day before, searching for some hint about who could be pounding on his door right now. "Ah..." He realized it suddenly in a fragmented memory from the last afternoon.

He'd been at the mailboxes all lined up in the wall of the downstairs entry to the apartment complex. He'd been rifling through the envelopes in his box, discarding the spam that came so thick in the season of the holidays, rich with capitalism when a small tap came on his shoulder.

He turned to see a slender reindeer standing just behind him, arms laden with packages, shopping bags, and shipping boxes. He wore skintight pair of jet black pants and tall chunky boots on bottom but a thick parka over top. His nose was red from the cold and antlers jutted up atop his head from a splay of ruffled hair. "He's cute..." Luster thought to himself, passingly. Also, he realized he didn't recognize the face at all from the apartment before.

"You look mighty strong" the reindeer said, voice lilting and musical. "Mind helping me carry some stuff up? The elevator is still broken down..."

Luster shrugged, nodding his head in agreement and taking half the load. Then, the reindeer swiveled around and starting bouncing up the steps. Luster hung behind, staring at the tight grip of his pants in his rounded bubble butt that swayed side to side with every step up the stairs he took. "What floor are you on?"

"Six!"

Luster nodded, thinking to himself that this gave him even more time to appreciate the energetic view from behind. "Same as me."

"Oh! Neighbors!" The reindeer chirped, voice filled with a chiming, delightful tone. "I'm Red, by the way."

"Luster-" the unicorn responded, realizing they were already hitting the floor landing. The reindeer, Red, led the way down to his door smothered in a thick wreath and rimmed in sparkly, festive garland.

"Tis the season, right?" Red said, flashing a sparkling smile over his shoulder before he set down his things and opened his arms for Luster's load. "Well, thank you, strong man Luster. I will be sure to thank you properly soon-"

Luster shrugged, "Don't worry about it."

But Red caught his eye with a sparkle in his own gaze. Luster saw something there, some daring twinkle that seemed to hint at something entirely different than a traditional thank you platter of cookies or a kind gesture in the hall. Then, too quick, the moment ended and they parted. Luster went home and hadn't thought of it again.

That is until now.

"Could that be him?" Luster thought with a tired groan, slowly letting gravity do the work of pulling him down to floor as he stood up. "God... Why?" he thought, momentarily catching sight of his morning wood jutting forward against the straining confinement of his boxers. "Fuck..." he grumbled, snagging a dressing gown off his door to cover it before he stumbled out into the hallway towards his apartment's front door where there came another softer knock.

Knock, knock.

"I'm coming!" Luster blurted, preceding his stumbling walk by a few moments before he flicked the lock and yanked open the door to see the same familiar reindeer standing in front of him.

"Oh! Did I wake you?" The male's face twisted into a pout.

Luster gave a shrug. "Nah. I needed to get up... Sorry it took so long." In his tired haze, Luster almost didn't see the plate held out to him, but as his eyes began to focus he noticed the platter the reindeer held out. "Ah, the classical thank you cookies..." Luster thought, nodding and thanking him as he took the plate.

"Sorry for waking you!" Red said with a smile that glimmered, then he was off.

Luster slipped back into his house, feeling his eyelids slowly starting to lighten up as he began to wake up finally. He let his feet thump their way into the kitchen, setting the coffee maker to brew as he slumped over the counter and peeled away the red-colored saran wrap to reveal a platter a cookies but something else too.

Luster squinted, rubbing away the final shred of sleep from his eyes. "Is that a... key?" His fingers moved onto the plate, plucking up the shining little metal shape. "It is a key..." As he lifted it, a gift tag tied with ribbon to its length fluttered along with.

There, in a careful scrawl, read a message.

Let me thank you for real tonight. I'll do... anything to repay you for sharing your superior strength with me (I hope you will again).

7 p.m

Red

Luster read the message once, then again. His mind blipped back to the glimmer he'd caught in the reindeer's eyes. "So... that wasn't imaginary?" he thought with a slight grin. His mind flashed to the tight, rounded ass he'd seen captured inside the tight hold of those black slacks.

"What does he mean by this though?" Luster started to think, realizing how little he actually knew about this character. He knew his name! That's all! "I mean... this is clearly flirtatious... but what if that's all..." Yet, at the same time, some part of him knew that the reindeer wasn't inviting him to a wine sampling. He'd seen it in his eyes, in the little parenthetical "(I hope you will again)".

"Share my strength, huh?" Luster felt his cheeks flush slightly, but his hard cock gave a throb from its fabric prison. "Not yet, bud. You might actually get some attention tonight..."

With that, Luster poured himself coffee and headed to the shower, wondering what the evening would bring.

*******

"Seven o'clock..." Luster muttered, lingering for a moment longer behind the safety of his apartment door. He didn't know what to expect down the hall. He didn't know how to prepare. He simply did not know.

"Well, worst case scenario.... I run into him in the hall every single day and feel awkward and hate myself... What's the big deal-" his voice petered off, the sarcasm dripping from his voice.

He pushed out of his own door, locking it behind him before he headed down the hall to the decked out door that he knew belonged to Red. Then, he gave a small knock on instinct before he remembered the small metallic key in his hand.

It felt alien and strange as he pushed the key into the door, unsealing someone else's house before he slowly pushed the door open.

His eyes instantly started to dart around the room, trying to get a map or a feel of this new place. He spotted a massive Christmas tree eating up the living room to the right, covered in glittering tinsel and bright red bulbs.

Garland covered surfaces all over the room, but it was hard to see in the dimmed lights. Far down the main hallway, Luster could see light spilling out from the bedroom. "I guess that's where I go?" he thought, tentatively starting to walk down the hall. He fought the urge to call out hello, but it somehow would break the spell.

So, instead, he walked steadily down the length of the hall. As he neared the bedroom's partially opened door, he caught a slim glimpse into the room. Warm red light spilled out from one corner of the room. His knuckle gave a small rap against the door's frame before he nudged it open with his foot.

"Red?" Luster voiced, stepping fully into the bedroom and searching for the reindeer. Finally, he saw he lounged back on the bed. He wore only a loose fitting t-shirt and a pair of briefs that hugged to the massive bulge in the front of them, straining against the fabric. The shirt flowed over his chest, hiding it from view.

"Strong Man," Red purred, meeting his eyes with a sparkling grin. "I would apologize for being so forward, but that'd simply be a lie... I don't feel bad about it at all..." He rose from the bed, moving lightly on his bare hooves as he approached the unicorn. "I just can't help myself when I see a big, strong man waiting around, looking lonesome." He smirked, catching Luster's flustered expression as pink colored up his gray furred cheeks.

"Besides, I owe you for your generous help..." Red's fingers slipped down the front of Luster's t-shirt, following the curved contours of his abdomen until he found the front of his jeans. He lingered for a moment, eyes flicking upwards to check Luster's face before he continued. One finger expertly twisted the metal button out of its home before he flicked the zipper down. Then, in a fluid movement, he dropped down to his knees in front of the unicorn.

Luster's eyes went wide, his chin nearly resting on his chest as he stared in dumbfounded confusion at the scene happening in front of him, to him.

"What is happening?' his mind demanded, struggling to understand how this near stranger could be casually dropping to his waist. Yet, at the same time, the sight of the slender man's body beneath him, with his fuzzy antlers jutting up, sent excited jolts up the unicorn's spine to compliment the warmth spreading as dainty fingers reached into his jeans, boldly grabbing for their target with a squeeze.

"Mmm..." Red crooned, peeking up with a grin. "Strong Man is a big boy" he teased, giving another tug onto the waistband of the jeans so they'd tumble to the ground entirely, leaving Luster's cock jutting out from his waist, proud and throbbing.

Then, without hesitation, the reindeer's lips spread open wide and pressed around the first inch. He sunk the hugging, hot ring of his mouth down over Luster's tip without ceremony or rush, just a slow, languid stroke down. Once he'd pushed past the first flared inch of his head, he paused with his tongue swirling around the captured girth with a testing taste before he backtracked, keeping the same slow pace. "Yummy too!"

Luster felt his cheeks flaring hotter, watching the reindeer below him, just kneeling on the carpet servicing him. In the back of his mind, a flurry of half-entertained thoughts were pulsing.

"I just met him yesterday!"

"He doesn't even 'owe' me, I just carried some stuff!"

"Well! Duh! That's just a ploy for this!"

"But he's doing all the work!"

"That's probably the point..."

Luster gave a jerk of his head, shaking away the thoughts and throwing himself instead into what was happening now. Yet, knowing the background, knowing this stranger had seen him and realizing that he wanted him and set out to have him was thrilling. It sent a heat down his spine.

A zing of "he wanted me."

A sudden gasp burst from the unicorn's mouth as he was yanked out of his cluttered head by a load, vocal slurp down his length. Red had suddenly transition from slow, teasing tasting of his flared head to entirely gulping down his entire length, as much as would fit in his first plunge down.

Luster's eyelids fluttered, feeling the hot wet grasp of the reindeer's mouth hugging around every inch of his cock. He started to bob next, building up to a hearty speed that he began to hold, licking around with his tongue as he kept the gulping, bobbing repetition up.

"Fuck..." Luster gasped, his hand reached out, instinctively looking for a grasping point and finding the velvety handles of the antlers bouncing in front of him. Red gave a low churr of encouragement as Luster's fingers wrapped around the slender appendage and started to tug along with the pace of his mouth slurping down over the slick skin of his cock.

His eyes tipped down, staring at the sight of it, repeating in a perfect loop as the reindeer bobbed down, nose kissing to his pelvis before he pulled back till just his lips kissed against the tip, fully releasing his cock from the warm grasp of his mouth before he repeated back down again.

The entire cycle was erotic, yet teasing. He lacked just enough speed, just enough pressure to finish the unicorn, and Luster was just realizing it.

"You're toying with me-" he blurted, almost not thinking the thought before it flew out of his mouth. Red grinned, the smile breaking the perfect O of his suctioning lips. "Maybe I am... What would you do about it?" his eyes glimmered again, daring him.

"Really now? You want to play that game?" Luster countered, his eyes wandering down behind the reindeer's shoulder where he could see the rounded shape of his ass jutting out and the throbbing bulge that was in the front, straining with the cock trapped inside.

"Oh. I assure you, I want to play that game." Red grinned, unraveling his tongue with a long swipe up Luster's shaft before the unicorn gave a tug, guiding him up by his antlers with just a hint of rough impatience. Red responded with a grin, leaning into Luster with hesitation with a long kiss.

Luster kissed back, dropping his hands to the male's slender waist and heaving him towards the bed. He found Red a lot lighter than he imagined, doll-like almost as he lifted him onto the comforter, following with his own body over top.

One hand abandoned its post mid-waist, roaming down instead to the clothed bulge at the front of the festive creature's briefs. He cupped over the hot shape, feeling the radiating warmth before his fingers gave a squeeze to find the shape of the trapped cock.

"Mm... Pretty Boy is big too now, isn't he?" he teased, whispering with his gruff voice into one floppy ear.

"I'm flattered you think so-" Red smirked, rolling his hips up into the grasping hand, but Luster quickly moved his fingers away from the center of his briefs to the waistband, stripping them away in a rush so his hands could both move back instead to grab at that meaty, teasing ass that'd been filling his head since yesterday.

"Fuck... Yes. I wanna be in there" he growled into Red's ear, kissing at his neck once, skimming teeth against the tender flesh.

"I said in my note... anything" Red said simply, flashing a cheeky grin before he was suddenly rolling. Luster flipped him onto his belly, relishing this new look at the soft, fleshy ass bare now except for the thin layer of warmed caramel fur. His hands grabbed greedily at the furred skin, kneading into them rounded shapes.

At the same time, his hips shuffled forward, drawing his cock up to the puckered hole of the other male's rump. Perfectly timed, Red's fingers lifted, dangling a slender bottle of lube over one shoulder, Luster squinted at the bottle.

"Christmas Candy Cane Flavored."

"Tingling Delight"

"Really?" Luster asked, chuckling briefly as his fingers absently went through the rush motions of popping the lid, starting the work of massaging the tingling, slippery, cold gel up to the tight puckered star in front of him. Red just glanced back, flashing that twinkling stare.

"What else could I expect?" Luster muttered with a shake of his head. "Fucking a reindeer."

With his back end lubed and dripping, Red gave a wiggling shake of his ass, pushing back against the waiting tip of Luster's cock. Luster grinned, meeting his invitation with a steady, slow shove forward. He could feel the tight ring trying to block him out, squeezing against his force, but then slowly, he felt its tentative give, the forced relaxation as Red pushed to him, welcoming him into the squeeze of his ass.

The first inch settling in, Luster could feel the walls contracting, massaging around him rapidly as they tried to figure out who this intruder was. Luster didn't pause, but he didn't rush. He kept feeding his cock into the small twink's ass, inch by inch, watching it stretch from his elevated viewpoint.

Finally, he bottomed out. He could feel every inch trapped inside, squeezing hard around him with massaging spasms. Red's moans were starting to echo back in the room, creating a chorus of his own voice at different volumes, different stages of responding back. Luster grabbed onto his ass, holding the soft flesh as a handle as he started to speed up.

Finally, after a day of waiting, nearly an hour by now of languid teasing, he could feel release in his future. He could feel the pulsing, beating, speeding rush of his heart in his cock, counting off its beats. He felt the oozing spread of precum lubing up the deep insides of the mewling reindeer's ass as he pumped hard.

The bed started to thump into the wall, counting off each thrust. Red didn't seem to notice, certainly didn't care. His fingers curled into the bed, clinging on as he shoved his ass back against Luster, invited whatever punishment he could give him.

Luster already felt himself started to verge on the edge, felt the hint of it in the distance. His breathing grew harder. His muscles started to ache, but he kept pace. He sped up slightly, grabbing harder onto the soft, supple handles of Red's body. Everytime he thrusted, the reindeer met his motions. His ass slapped into Luster's waist with every thrust, echoing out the smacking sound through the air as his squeaking moans rang out. "F-fuck..." Luster grunted, straining to hold off longer, to enjoy this a bit longer. Red, however, wasn't letting him pause. Red's ass pushed harder to him, nearly fucking him backwards.

"I'm guh-na..." Luster got out before he felt it hit him.

The first spurt went deep into the reindeer's ass, filling him with spreading spooge as Luster drew back slightly, letting the next streams shallower, anticipating how they'd ooze out when he finished. After another string, and another, he finally drew back. His tip, the plug, pulled out from the stretched, tired ass with a leaking line of goo following. The creamy white filling leaked out, lining Red's ass with creamy, glittering white.

Luster huffed, sitting back as he watched Red roll over with a grin. "Awh... Silly me! I meant to pay you back! But you did all the work!" He bounced up, seemingly not even phased by the round they'd already had. His hands found Luster's shoulders, pushing and guiding him back to lean into the headboard. "Here, let's try to even out the score..."

He paused a moment, raising his ass once more over Luster's lap before he spoke with a wink. "After all, I'd hate to still be in your debt~"