Second Date
Story by Wyatt on SoFurry
#5 of Teenagers
Yes, there\'s been a huge delay with this chapter, mainly because I got... eh hem... lost in other things (couldn\'t be bothered). But, hey, here it is again! Enjoy! ^_^
\"Ouch... Oh man...\"
Even the sound of his own voice was like a knife to the skull. Dylan was lying in a bed, which he instantly recognized as his own. He opened his eyes, but the light hurt his pupils so much that he had to shut them again.
How much did he remember? He could remember being with Wyatt before they fell asleep together. Then he remembered being driven home, climbing into his own bed and that was about it... He could have sworn, however, that there was something else he\'d forgotten.
He suddenly rolled over, and felt his paw brush against something solid. Hang on... it felt like... fur... He opened his eyes. At the same time, he saw another pair of bright green eyes staring back at him.
\"W...Wyatt?!\" Dylan yelped and jumped up.
Wyatt reacted in a similar way. \"Whoa... I wasn\'t that drunk, was I?!\" the tiger groaned. Both of them were completely naked, and darted to cover their crotches.
\"Hang on...\" Dylan said, his heart thumping. \"This didn\'t happen! I can\'t remember it! When did you...?\"
Neither of them spoke. They just stared at each other, totally lost for words. Eventually, Dylan cleared his throat. \"We should... get changed.\"
\"Yeah...\"
Whilst Wyatt looked away, Dylan got changed. He dressed into his usual pair of jeans, and had been about to pull his shirt over his head when he noticed, to his horror, a small stain on the arm. \"Oh god.\" He mumbled to himself. He chose a different shirt.
\"Done.\" Dylan said, and turned around so Wyatt could get changed. As he heard the tiger fumbling around, he suddenly had a very strong urge to glance behind him... just for a second... NO! Wait! That was wrong!
\"What\'re we going to do?\" Wyatt asked, his voice slightly weak.
\"Pretend it never happened?\"
\"We can\'t just do that! Things will never be the same between us! I mean... there\'s you and Theo, and then there\'s-\"
\"Me and Theo haven\'t spoken for a long time now.\" Dylan interrupted Wyatt. At that, a cold, awkward silence fell between them. Dylan couldn\'t help but think he was subconsciously suggesting that he and Theo had broken up.
\"I\'m gonna\' take a shower, if that\'s ok?\"
\"Oh, sure!\" Dylan smiled, but the expression wasn\'t returned. As he watched Wyatt walk away towards the shower, he couldn\'t help but feel... attached to him. Did he... have a crush on Wyatt now?
He thought back. It was so difficult to remember how he felt when he was around Theo, since the two had spoken for so long. He couldn\'t recall how it felt to love somebody for real, so he couldn\'t be sure about his feelings for Wyatt.
Maybe it was just lust? Hopefully...
Dylan leant against the wall, right outside the bathroom. Inside he could hear the shower water running. Wyatt was right inside... Dang! If only he could see through walls!
No! He loved Theo! Th_eeee_- oooooooo!
\"Hey Wyatt?\" Dylan called, louder than usual to make his voice heard over the running water.
\"Yeah?\"
\"Promise you won\'t freak out or anything?\"
\"Freak out over what?\"
\"Well... is it wrong that I still think you\'re really hot?\"
At that exact moment, the door into the bathroom swung open and a small, orange paw reached out and grabbed Dylan by the cuff, tugging him forcefully into the humid, steamy room. He felt shower water dripping onto his dry clothes, and yelped in protest. But, even as he opened his mouth, Wyatt pushed him against the wall and kissed him deeply, blocking off any chance of him ever getting a word out.
At first Dylan\'s eyes were wide with shook, but he quickly relaxed, and leaned quite willfully into the tiger\'s warm embrace. He didn\'t care that his clothes were soaked. Why should he? He was in the shower with a cute, naked tiger! What was there not to enjoy about this?
He\'d never kissed anyone so... well... violently. The pair tilted their heads in opposite directions, to avoid their noses banging together. Their tongues darted and twisted playfully between each other, and at one point Dylan even felt his front teeth hit Wyatt\'s.
His shirt was, willfully, tugged clean off of his head and thrown onto the wet floor. Dylan only stopped kissing Wyatt for a second, just to let his shirt pass through the gap, and then dived at him again. He pushed himself off the wall and shoved Wyatt backwards, quite literally pinning him against the tiles, completely lost in his own lusts. Hot water from the showerhead soaked his fur, but he didn\'t care. His thoughts were fixed on just one thing, and that was the tiger in his arms.
After the initial burst of aroused aggression, the pair calmed down. They continued their long kiss, but much slower... more gentle. The water trickling down Dylan\'s body and the feel of another warm person pressed against him was more than he could take. He moaned quietly as a large pressure began forming in his wet boxers. Luckily, however, he could feel a similar bulge forming on Wyatt. He wasn\'t alone in all this.
He looked down, and his heart began to race faster at the sight of Wyatt\'s fully erect shaft, which was a much greater sight now that he was sober. It looked perfect in every way... if he were to just imagine a random dick, this would be it. He took hold of it with one paw, whilst placing his laps back over the tiger\'s and began stroking it rhythmically. Wyatt\'s claws lightly dug into his back. A sign of pleasure, defiantly. He returned the favor speeding the movements of his paw, working faster and tirelessly. He felt as though he was going to loose grip any second, but that didn\'t stop him.
And then, out of nowhere, Theo appeared in his head...
Wyatt\'s next kiss only met the side of Dylan\'s cheek. He\'d stopped jacking the tiger off, and was now looking at the wall, avoiding eye contact.
\"W...what... what\'s wrong?\" Wyatt asked, slightly breathless. \"I was about to cum!\"
Dylan didn\'t answer. An incredible surge of guilt had just taken him over. \"I can\'t do this... it\'s wrong...\" he said, and hopped out of the shower.
Wyatt\'s paw landed on his shoulder and turned him around. The tiger looked concerned. \"Wait! What\'s up?\"
\"It\'s Theo!\" Dylan lightly pushed Wyatt\'s paw off of him. \"I couldn\'t do this to him. It\'s not fair.\" Wyatt didn\'t answer. Without giving the tiger a chance to say anything, Dylan left the room.
He felt terrible now. How could he have let a simple lust take control of him so suddenly? It had just been one slip, but he\'d taken it way too far! Did he have no control? Was he just an unstable cum slut, waiting to break somebody\'s heart?
He got changed into a dry set of clothes and, with patience, waited for Wyatt to leave the bathroom, fully clothes. The two stared at each other.
\"I\'m sorry, Dylan.\" Wyatt said quietly. \"I better go, ok?\"
\"Wait.\" Dylan said as Wyatt began to turned around. The tiger tilted his head back. \"It\'s not that I don\'t like you, because I do. I really do! But... with Theo...\"
\"I know, don\'t worry.\"
\"I don\'t know if I can ever face him again now. Even before, when he lied to me, at least we had a chance. Now I don\'t know how I feel.\"
Wyatt sighed. There was a long, drawn out silence between them. \"Do you love me, or not?\"
Shit, that was a personal question, wasn\'t it? Dylan coughed. \"I don\'t... know. I think I do.\"
Wyatt turned around. \"It\'s either me or Theo, ok? Sorry... but you can\'t have both. I...\" he blushed. \"I really, really like you... but I\'m not gonna\' get involved with you if you still love Theo.\" And with that, the tiger left.
Ring...
Ring...
Ring...
\"Come on, Theo! Answer your fucking phone, you great, big, fat fucking-\"
\"Hello?\"
\"Theo!\" Dylan silently prayed that the cheetah hadn\'t heard what he\'d been saying. \"I didn\'t think you\'d answer.\"
\"Were you just talking to yourself?\"
Dylan froze. \"Umm...\" well, that was less embarrassing, \"Yes! Yes, I was.\"
\"Oh...\"
\"Look, I just wanted to call you up and talk. I know it\'s been ages... but...\"
He heard Theo laugh. \"Don\'t worry, ok? I know I let you down, and I wouldn\'t have told Tom you were gay in the first place.\"
Dylan sighed. \"Look, Theo, I\'m really sorry I snapped like that. Turns out telling Tom was a good thing – he\'s been really supportive.\"
\"Hang on!\" Theo interrupted him, \"I thought you wanted me to apologies to you?\"
\"That was stupid! I was just being an idiot! I overreacted... got caught up in all the drama of being a teenager or something, I don\'t know...\"
There was a pause. Theo cleared his throat. \"Well, it\'s ok. I\'m fine, and I just hope you\'re ok too.\"
\"I am!\"
\"Great! So...\" Theo\'s voice became chirpier, happier and more upbeat. \"...Any chance of us picking things off where we left?\"
Dylan smiled. \"I was hoping you\'d say that.\"
Second date.
Although, to Dylan, it felt like it was his and Theo\'s first date all over again. He stood outside the cinema, pretending to text someone on his phone to avoid attention, waiting for the cheetah to turn up. His tail was wrapped nervously around his waist, and he avoided eye contact with anybody. He was more nervous than he had been on his first date.
\"Hey! Dylan!\" A familiar, warm voice called to him from the side. Dylan looked up to see Theo walking towards him.
\"Oh, great... he looks even cuter now!\" Dylan cursed to himself. He could have sworn, even at this distance, that the cheetah had been working out.
\"You ok?\" Theo asked, frowning. Dylan had been staring for some time.
\"Yeah!\" he snapped out of his daze. \"I\'m ok! I just... haven\'t seen you for ages.\"
They both blushed together. \"Aww, I missed you too, Fuzzball!\" Theo chuckled, ruffling Dylan\'s hair. \"I felt really lonely without that black lil\' panther beside me.\"
\"Who\'re you calling little?! You\'re just big!\"
Theo shrugged. \"Maybe, but you\'re still the cute one.\" He said, rubbing the back of his neck.
Dylan blushed again. \"Whatever. I\'m just glad you\'re back.\"
\"Yeah.\" Theo looked around. \"So can I hug you, or what? I wouldn\'t wanna\' make people suspicious of us.\" He said with a wink.
Dylan rolled his eyes. \"I\'m not that suspicious of people!\" he smirked, then grabbed Theo around the waist and pulled them together.
Dylan wasn\'t entirely sure what movie they were going to see. In fact, he wasn\'t even sure what was on. Theo had bought some tickets and, at some point, told him what the film was, but Dylan had only nodded in agreement. Every time Theo turned around Dylan just couldn\'t stop... staring at him!
It was a relief when they finally got into the theatre. They sat in silence. Dylan wondered if Theo was just as nervous as he was... come to think of it, why was he so distraught? He\'d been with Theo plenty of times before without feeling like this... why now?
It was quite a shock when he felt a furry paw clasp itself around his. He blinked, as though in confusion, and then saw Theo frowning at him. \"Are you ok?\"
\"Yes!\" Dylan snapped back instantly. \"I\'m fine, I swear!\"
\"...Right.\" Theo looked suspicious. \"Are you sure?\"
\"Yeah, just a little tense.\"
Theo smiled, and put his arm warmly around Dylan\'s shoulders, hugging him close. \"This any better?\"
Dylan murred. \"Uhh... huh...\" There was something about being this close to Theo that always relaxed him. He could just... float away.
It suddenly struck him that, after what happened between him and Wyatt, could he just be feeling guilty? He had, in a way, cheated on Theo... even though he thought they had broken up, but they hadn\'t.
But, now, when he looked up at Theo, he couldn\'t help but think... what the hell had I been thinking? Wyatt didn\'t mean anything to him now! Theo was bigger, cuter, sweeter and much, much more romantic.
He smiled. Yeah, Theo would look after him.
Dylan hadn\'t being paying any attention to the film, right through to the end. In fact, he\'d spent the entire hour addictively nuzzling Theo\'s chest, enjoying the full comfort of his warmth and company. When the film ended, however, he didn\'t feel so... insecure about being with him.
\"That film was crap...\" Theo grinned as he got up. \"Honestly, I\'ve seen better-\"
Dylan cut him off. He knew that there were people around them, but he finally felt as though he could ignore. Though it wasn\'t a serious, deep moment, Dylan\'s kiss was still enough to send them both into an odd trance. When they broke apart, Dylan was smirking, and Theo was staring at him curiously.
\"What happened to the whole ‘not in public\' thing?\"
Dylan shrugged. \"I got over it. Nobody\'s looking, are they?\"
\"Nope.\" Theo said, with a smile.
They left the theatre, arm in arm, and in deep conversation. Dylan had never felt so close to him. He felt as though nothing could possibly break them apart now. Nothing! What could go wrong?
But it was only once they turned to leave the cinema that Dylan\'s heart missed a beat at the sight he saw.
Walking straight at them, paws locked, was Wyatt and a canine that Dylan had never seen before. Both of them were smiling. Wyatt and Dylan saw each other, and froze. Theo frowned, and then saw Wyatt.
\"Hey! Wyatt!\" The cheetah waved at them. \"What\'re you doing here?\"
Dylan gulped. He looked down at the ground, and pretended to be nuzzling Theo, just to avoid eye contact with Wyatt.
\"Umm... just... stuff.\" Wyatt muttered. By the sounds of things, the tiger sounded as though things just as awkward for him.
\"Cool. Who\'s this?\" Theo asked, pointing at the canine, who immediately straightened up and shook Theo\'s paw.
\"I\'m Colin. So are you Wyatt\'s friend...?\"
\"Friend-of-a-friend. Dylan here is a friend of Wyatt\'s.\"
\"Oh.\" Colin smiled at Dylan and waved. \"Nice to meet you, I guess.\"
Dylan nodded, and mumbled something incoherent.
\"Well, we better go!\" Wyatt said through an easily fake smile, and practically tugged Colin past Dylan and Theo.
Dylan and Wyatt briefly exchanged a slightly inhibited glance.
That was odd. How had Wyatt gotten himself a date so quickly, after him and Dylan had fooled around?
Unless, Dylan realized, that Wyatt had been going out with Colin from the start? In that case, why hadn\'t he said anything! Had he and Wyatt both cheated on their respective boyfriends at the same time or something? Something seemed odd here...
\"Colin seemed nice.\" Theo said, \"Maybe we should double date or something!\"
Oh god...
As usual, I never really proof-check my work... so enjoy the spelling errors! They love you, really, they do! :)
Toodle-pip xxx