The Wrong Catch

Story by Paragon Panda on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Jason is on a fishing trip when he accidentally catches an anthro shark girl. He's scared at first, but on closer inspection it turns out she may have been a better catch than any fish.


(Note: All characters in this story are 18 or older)

Jason, a normal human man, was on vacation. He loved the ocean, and decided to go off on a deep sea fishing trip. So he took his boat to the beach, motored out way past the buoys, attached a net to the stern and made a few quick rounds. Eventually, he noticed that the net had something wriggling in it, his face lighting up. He wondered what kind of fish he'd managed to snag...

He stopped the boat and went to pull in the net, a smile on his face as he anticipated his catch... Only to see something he hadn't been expecting. Tangled up in the net looked like... A person? No, but it only looked human... As he pulled it up, he realized the net had a shark trapped in it. Surprised, he stumbled back, falling backwards onto the deck of his boat and yelped in surprise. He caught a shark!? Getting it out of the net was gonna be dangerous...

"Hey you creep, what's the big idea!?" He heard a youthful female voice call out, "Lemme outta here!"

Jason blinked, realizing that the voice had come from the shark. Oh right... It was an anthro after all. He stumbled back up, sitting down on the back steps of his boat and taking a closer look at the shark.

"Um... Sorry... I was just trying to catch some fish..."

He looked the shark girl up and down. She looked young, probably around the human equivalent of 18. As expected of such a powerful animal, she was very slim and toned... And from the coloration sne seemed like a Great White.

"I don't care what you were trying to do! You still trapped me! Now get me out of here or I'll bite!"

Jason blushed as he realized the girl was naked. He could see her budding A cup breasts, that smooth crotch... And while her butt was facing away from him, he could see that her hips were very nicely proportioned... Even the powerful tail was kinda attractive... He was getting ideas...

"H-hey! Are you listening to me?" She whined, squirming more within the net, "I said lemme go!"

Well, it was now or never. No one else was around... He smirked over at her.

"Well, it'd only be ethical to let you go, obviously..." He began, "But I want you to do me a favor first~"

She raised an eyebrow, stopping her squirming for a second.

"A favor!? You want ME to do something for YOU? I could tear you in half!"

"You want out of the net don't you? I don't have to get close enough for you to bite me you know."

She huffed, rolling her eyes.

"Fine... What do you want?"

Jason's smirk grew into a smile, and his heart began to race. He answered quickly, before his nerves could hold him back.

"I wanna have sex before you go back into the ocean."

He expected a response of anger, but instead she blushed and donned a sheepish expression.

"Y-you wanna mate? Seriously...? B-but I just threatened to kill you..."

Her response gave Jason a confidence boost, his expression growing more lewd.

"Are you kidding? You're cute as hell! Of course I wanna mate. So what'll it be?"

She blushed more, trying her best to cover herself up.

"There's really no other way you'll let me go...?"

"Nope. It's either have sex or stay in that net."

"F-fine... Just get me outta here already..."

Jason grinned, taking the net aboard the boat and helping her out of it. The shark girl seemed embarrassed, immediately covering herself up.

"I-I could still kill you, you know..."

He however didn't seem to care. He stood over her, slipping his swim trunks down to expose his eight inches of cock to her.

"Yeah? Well I don't think you will~"

Her eyes didn't seem to move from that big, thick cock of his. She didn't respond to him... Actions that spelled 'submissive' to Jason. He moved down, steadily pushing her arm away from where it was covering her breasts, spreading her legs as well.

"You're so cute...~" he complimented her as he ran his hands along her body, rubbing his cock right up against the soft flesh of her pussy. As expected of a shark, she was very smooth one way, and very rough the other.

"J-just do it already..." She whined, very unbecoming of her tough exterior.

"With pleasure~"

He cupped her breasts in his hands, lining up the tip of his cock with her pussy and slowly pushing in. Despite herself, she let out a very cute moan as that huge, thick rod penetrated her. Glad that she seemed not to have a hymen, he steadily pushed all eight inches into her. It was one of the best feelings he'd ever experienced, her powerful muscles and small frame causing her pussy to be incredibly tight.

"Holy fuck...~"

Without waiting for a response from her, he pulled back and began pounding her cunt as hard as he could. She was uncontrollably squealing and moaning as he completely railed her. She had a hard grip on a nearby guard rail, her tail squirming powerfully underneath them. One of his hands ran down her toned stomach, feeling her strong abs. She couldn't seem to talk, her pussy muscles already starting to grow tighter. He could tell that she was gonna cum soon, and it made him get closer as well. There was no way he could pull out of her, it felt too good...

Soon the moment came, and her climax hit. She threw her head back, crying out in pleasure as her walls spasmed and hugged his cock tightly. Jason moaned as well, her climax triggering his own. He pushed himself balls deep into her pussy, feeling his tip press against her cervix as rope after rope of his thick cum spewed right into her womb. The hand that was on her stomach pressed down as he was caught up in the moment, inadvertently stimulating her into ovulating.

Eventually their mutual climax died down, and Jason was the first to come to his senses. He realized what he had done, and smirked down at her.

"You know you're probably gonna get pregnant from this right?"

She huffed up at him.

"Dummy... What else is mating for... Of course I am..."

He leaned down and kissed her, causing her eyes to widen. Thankfully she didn't respond violently, and he looked right into her eyes as he broke the kiss.

"I wanna do it one more time before you go... To make sure."

He slowly pulled out of her cunt, watching as thick globs of his seed poured out of it. He helped her up, only to bend her over the guard rail of his boat.

"I want you to ask for it this time."

She pouted before looking back at him, this time with lustful eyes. It seemed she was fully into this now.

"Please... Mister human..." She said, moving her tail out of the way so he could see her tight ass and dripping cunt, "Mate with me again... And make sure I have your pups~"

Jason grinned, getting in behind her and shoving right back into her pussy. He held her close with one hand, spanking her with the other as he slammed into her cunt again and again. As before, she kept yelping every time he pushed into her. Only from this angle he could more easily smack into her cervix. She looked like she was in heaven, unabashedly screaming out for the entire sea to hear the sounds of their coupling. It wasn't long before the telltale signs of her climax reared up again, and his cock throbbed powerfully inside her as he anticipated it. Soon the two came together once more, her pussy muscles squeezing and milking his rod for all it was worth. And boy did he give her what she wanted. This second load was even bigger than the last, and he kept himself buried balls deep into this lewd little teen shark as he filled her with every drop of it.

"Fuck... I dunno if I'll ever have sex this good again..." He panted as he finally pulled out, seeing his cum spill out of her once again. The shark girl fell limp, panting hard. Her legs wobbled, her knees clearly weak.

"Me either..." She finally managed to say, looking back at him again, "But I have to go back into the ocean sometime..."

Jason sat down in one of the boat's seats, still panting from the exhaustion of all that rough sex.

"I know... Go whenever you're ready..."

Much to his surprise however, the shark wobbled over and sat down. Then they just... Sat there and talked for a while. They talked about whatever random things came to mind, and it turned out they got along pretty well... Although eventually, the sun would begin to set. The two said their goodbyes without ever having exchanged names... And Jason promised to eventually come back to mate with her again.