15: That Pony From Her Past

Story by krisprowler on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


The second week of performances for Starshadow went just as well as her first set of concerts, if not better. The first concert brought in just as many ponies as last week, all of them cheering loudly as she took the stage to play. Hoping to help Vinyl out of her state of depression Starshadow invited her to come play with her. The DJ agreed to come, but only as a member of the audience. She said she wasn't in the mood to play that night, plus she wanted to be able to enjoy Starshadow's music without having to worry about keeping up with her. Once the music started, Starshadow saw that bringing Vinyl Scratch with her was exactly what she needed; in no time at all Vinyl was back to her old self, dancing like a filly on a sugar high and shamelessly flirting with many of the ponies around her.

Word got out that Vinyl was attending a concert as a spectator, and one of the local journalists rushed over to see it for himself. He caught up with her after the show and asked her to comment on the music she had just heard. Vinyl usually hated dealing with any form of paparazzi, but since she was still reminiscing in her feeling of euphoria she decided to give her honest opinion of the concert. "Hey, this mare playing here on the weekends is the best! I don't team up with just anypony, they gotta be able to keep up with me. I've played with a lot of other musicians, but this mare is one of the best I've ever played with. You'd be stupid to not come to one of these shows!" The ponies crowded around her cheered in agreement, solidifying Starshadow's new reputation as the hottest musician playing in Ponyville.

The next night's show proved that the power of a celebrity endorsement was greater than anypony could predict. Even though the article with Vinyl's endorsement was just in the local Ponyville newspaper, the bigger paper companies in Manehattan, Fillydelphia, Baltimare, Canterlot, Cloudsdale, and Los Pegasus all picked up on the story and immediately sent their own reporters to the small town to catch her last show until next week. Almost everypony from the night before returned, wanting to prove that they were her fans first and possibly solidify a place as one of her original fans. The local ponies who hadn't been to one of Starshadow's shows yet also turned up to see what all the talk was about, and the combination of the three groups quickly caused that night's show to be sold out.

As Starshadow walked on stage she was shocked by the overwhelming crowd that packed the room. She couldn't believe that so many ponies would turn up for her music. The only time she had seen so many ponies was when she played her first concert here alongside Vinyl Scratch, and she knew for a fact that Vinyl had stayed home tonight. Part of her expected some of the crowd to leave when they saw that Vinyl wouldn't be playing with her or in the crowd this time, but she was proven very wrong when the crowd once again let out a deafening roar. She paused for a second, reality taking a few moments to sink in as she realized that every single pony was here to see and listen to HER. She couldn't help but smile as she started playing her keyboard, the crowd of ponies cheering once more before they let the music take over.

Her music was by far the biggest success of all the ponies playing that night, and the audience demanded two encores before Starshadow wrapped up her night. By the time the party had ended and Starshadow was able to start walking home it was almost 3 AM. Bar Back congratulated her on such a successful night before heading back inside to clean up the massive mess left by the hundreds of ponies. Starshadow sighed happily, glad that her night was over and that she could finally head home and rest. She thought of the plans she had made with Big Mac for tomorrow; a small picnic in the orchard before heading to Fluttershy's cottage as the timid mare had asked for their help in setting up a new bird bath.

Still feeling energized by the successful concert, Starshadow decided to take the long way home, passing by the river that ran through the town and found herself at the edge of the fields of Sweet Apple Acres. She propped herself up on the fence bordering the massive apple orchard and looked out at the fully laden trees and thought of Big Mac. No doubt the strong stallion would be awake within the next few hours and be out in the fields before the sun would rise, working up a sweat as his strong hind legs caused the trees to give up their fruit. Just imagining his body covered in sweat was starting to turn her on, and she closed her eyes and imagined the smell of his masculinity. She thought back to the last time they had mated; a quick bucking in the barn after he had finished plowing the corn fields all by himself. The smell of his sweaty body and the energy he still somehow had left inside of him had caused her to lose all control and submit to him almost immediately, and as she imagined him slowly inserting his member into her small body she began to touch herself.

"Still quite the slut, I see." a voice behind her said. Starshadow gasped and quickly removed her hoof from her crotch before turning around to see who had spoken. She saw another pegasus standing a few feet away, a sly smirk on his face. She recognized him as the pony she had seen a few days before that she thought she knew from somewhere else. Try as she might, she still couldn't figure out who he was or where she may have seen him before.

"I... I..." Starshadow stuttered, but the pegasus held up a hoof to her lips to silence her.

"Shh, don't worry, it's nothing I haven't seen you do before." he said. The blank look on her face let him know that she didn't recognize him at all, causing him to chuckle. "Of course you wouldn't recognize me. You've slept with so many stallions we're all just one faceless group by now. Now turn back around and get back up on that fence. Now."

Starshadow wanted to say no but her body responded on its own, and she found herself doing exactly as the stallion had commanded. She shivered as she felt him lift up her tail but couldn't bring herself to tell him to stop or kick out at him as her old training was beginning to resurface and she wanted to see just what he was up to.

"Hmm, just as I thought, still a complete slut who gets off on having other ponies watch her. But this time I won't just be watching, I'll get to enjoy your body too." the stallion said gleefully, prodding her moistening sex with his hoof.

Starshadow's mind raced as a torrent of conflicting emotions ran through her head. She wanted to give in to his forceful advances and give herself up to this stallion, but something in her mind was causing her to resist. Something in her heart hurt and she couldn't help but think of Big Mac. Still, she was having trouble understanding the new feelings and emotions she had discovered after meeting Big Mac, and right now she was more conflicted than ever.

"W- hnng.... wait a sec." Starshadow tried to say but her pleas turned into moans as the stallion began to rub his hoof against her sensitive button. She glanced back at the stallion toying with her and locked eyes with him but was still unable to figure out who he was.

Her assaulter noticed the look of confusion still in her eyes and laughed. "You really don't remember me, do you?" he asked. "Well, that's no surprise. You spent most of your time fucking Slick... greedy bastard never did like to share. I remember you, though. I followed you home every day to that house in Los Pegasus and wanted to use you myself, but then things got bad and you disappeared before I could finally make my move."

Something finally clicked inside of Starshadow's head and she remembered where she had seen him before. He had been one of the gang ponies under the unicorn that found her wandering the streets and took her in to use her as a toy, and she also recalled seeing him following her home a few times. The stallion saw her expression change and he smiled in satisfaction. "I see you finally remember me." he said gleefully. "Don't worry, Thunderlane will take good care of you. You're mine to use now." As he spoke to her he pressed harder on her clit, and as he finished his last sentence he began to rub her sensitive button as fast as he could, causing Starshadow's body to shake as she came from his touch. He kept up his rubbing, forcing a second orgasm out of the little mare that seamlessly blended in with and amplified her first one.

Thunderlane finally broke contact with Starshadow and stepped back to admire his work. Starshadow lay slumped over the wooden fence rail, her hind legs quivering slightly from the quick double orgasm she was still coming down from. A few drops of her juices dripped off of her lower lips and either ran down her legs or fell straight to the ground before being absorbed by the dirt. Not wanting to let too much of her fluids to go to waste, Thunderlane leaned forward and began lapping at her pussy with his tongue, drinking in her nectar eagerly like a pony finding an oasis in the Saddle Arabian Desert.

Starshadow gasped as his tongue made contact with her, and she couldn't stop herself from thrusting her body backwards so she could feel Thunderlane's tongue against her pussy even more. Her breathing began to become ragged again and she began losing every single thought except for wanting more pleasure. To her annoyance, Thunderlane seemed to know exactly when to stop and pulled away from her just as her third orgasm was beginning to build. "Wha- mnnnggg, don't stop." she begged.

Thunderlane smirked again as her reaction was just what he wanted. He grabbed her tail with his mouth and yanked on it hard, pulling her off of the fence and dumped her body on the ground. Nudging her hard so she was now lying on her back, Thunderlane stood back and exposed his erect cock to her. "You want this, you whorse? You want it that badly?"

Stashadow nodded desperately. "Yes, I want it! I need it! Please, put it inside of me. Use me all you want." she begged him.

"Do you? Then prove it." Thunderlane demanded. "Let me watch you touch yourself and I'll decide if you want it badly enough."

Starshadow didn't waste any time and did as she was told. She began to rub her engorged clit and moaned from the self stimulation. Thunderlane watched as she toyed with herself, her goal not to get herself off but to put on the best show possible for this aggressive stallion in hopes that he would reward her. "Mmm, look at how wet I am, look how badly I want you inside of me. Please, don't make me wait." she begged as she rubbed herself.

Thunderlane looked on hungrily as he watched Starshadow's sex become wetter and wetter. It wasn't long before she stopped playing with herself for show and she began masturbating for her own pleasure, forgetting that she had a one pony audience. She brought her other hoof down to poke around her rear entrance while the first hoof continued to toy with her foal hole, and she began to bring herself up to a much needed orgasm.

"Stop, no more." Thunderlane suddenly commanded. Starshadow froze, wanting to desperately continue as she was so close to cumming. Her hips bucked up slightly in desperation but she obeyed his command, waiting to see what he was going to do next. He stared down at her, basking in the power he held over her. "Aww, what's the matter? Were you about to cum? Do you want to cum for me that badly?" he teased.

Starshadow nodded furiously. "Yes! Please, let me cum! I was so close!" she said in desperation, her mind not thinking clearly at all.

Thunderlane moved up over her body and positioned his cock at her entrance, rubbing the tip against her slick opening. "Wouldn't you rather cum from my cock being inside of you? Wouldn't you prefer to feel my hot seed inside your body?"

That feeling of doubt began to rise up again as Big Mac's face flashed in her head. However, the thought was drowned out by her desire for satisfaction. "Yes, yes please, put it in me!" Starshadow begged. "I want you to make me cum! Please, give me your seed, let me feel it inside of me!"

Her begging was more than he had expected, but he loved every second of it. Not wanting to delay the pleasure he had been waiting so long for, he thrust his hips forward and buried his member into her tight wet pussy in one long stroke. Starshadow cried out as her earlier frustration melted away as he entered her. She couldn't help but wrap her hind legs around his waist and pull him deeper in to her, wanting him to fill her as much as possible. Thunderlane of course noticed her movements and held himself in place inside of her and leaned down to whisper into her ear. "You like that don't you? You like feeling me inside of you, right?" he whispered to her. She nodded and tried to answer him, but he quickly jerked his hips back and thrust forward, causing her answer to be replaced by a moan of pleasure. "You like that, huh? I can make you feel so much better. All you have to do is accept me and promise to be mine and only mine, and I'll make you feel this good all the time."

Starshadow was about to submit herself completely to him when Big Mac's face once again flashed through her mind. That same sickening feeling began to return to her, but this time it didn't simply fade away like it had done before; this time, it stayed inside of her and wouldn't go away. The small voice that had been trying to tell her that this was wrong, that she was making a horrible mistake, began to grow louder, and while she would normally give in and submit to any pony this forceful in a heartbeat, this time she wanted to say...

"No... no, I can't." Starshadow finally said.

Thunderlane was dumbstruck. "What did you just say?" he asked in bewilderment.

"I... I can't. I can't do that. I... Big Mac is my Master, he's my..." she replied, the words 'special somepony' almost slipping out of her mouth at the end.

Thunderlane's mood completely changed as he heard her disobey him. The entire time she spent as his old gang leader's mare she never once disobeyed one of his commands, and he took her disobeying him as her telling him that he was a weak leader. Unable to control his anger, his hoof lashed out and he struck the side of Starshadow's face. Her head snapped to one side as his hoof made contact, her eyes instantly tearing up from the sharp stinging pain now shooting through her cheek.

"You can't, or you won't?" Thunderlane yelled at her. She remained silent in shock from the first strike, so he hit her again. However, when he hit her the second time she let out a noise that almost sounded like a muffled moan and he felt her pussy tighten around his cock. "Oh, you like that, do you? You want more?" he sneered, striking her a third time.

Tears sprang to Starshadow's eyes, not out of pain from Thunderlane's hoof but from the emotional conflict still raging in her head. Being hit and physically hurt was nothing new to her, but the emotional conflict she felt was, and it scared her. "No more. Please, don't..." she begged him.

His patience gone, Thunderlane wrapped her mane around his hoof and pulled hard, causing her head to snap back just as he began to forcefully fuck her again. "You... will... be... MINE." he said with each rough thrust, keeping her head pulled back painfully.

His rough treatment began to finally overwhelm her. "Y-yes... okay. I'll be... I'll be yo-" she started to say.

Thunderlane quickly looked up as a crashing noise somewhere in the trees caught his attention. He looked up just in time to see two very angry looking ponies charging at him, and the look of absolute rage in one of the pony's eyes told Thunderlane that now would be a good time to leave. He quickly removed himself from Starshadow and turned to run just as Big Mac and Applejack jumped over the fence. Big Mac was completely focused on catching the stallion who had just been raping his special somepony, and even as Thunderlane took to the skies he still refused to give up the chase.

With her brother already in hot pursuit of the rapist, Applejack stopped to help Starshadow up and get her back to Sweet Apple Acres. "C'mon, sugarcube, yer safe now." she reassured the pegasus mare, trying to help her up. She found Starshadow to be more difficult than she thought as the abused mare was still lost in her lust. Thinking back to what bits she remembered while in her own heat, Applejack facehoofed herself as what she needed to do began to dawn on her. "Ya gotta be kiddin' me." she groaned, but there was no other choice.

Slowly approaching the other mare, Applejack reluctantly reached out, her hoof aimed at Starshadow's throbbing cunt. AJ was almost afraid that her touch would further hurt Starshadow, but as she finally made contact with Starshadow's crotch the pegasus let out a ragged sigh of relief and thrust her hips up, desperately seeking more attention. Applejack didn't have much choice but to oblige, using her hoof to rub Starshadow's crotch to build up her orgasm.

Starshadow didn't quite realize that Thunderlane was gone or that Applejack was now the pony touching her. All she cared about was that release that had been denied to her again and again, but now she was getting close and she couldn't stand the thought of having it taken away from her again. "Yes, more... I'm so close..." she gasped desperately. "Please, let me cum! I need to cum!"

Applejack swallowed, unable to believe that she was really helping her brother's special somepony get off like this. "Come on sugarcube, go ahead an' cum." Applejack said, hoping her words would help Starshadow hurry up.

Her words were exactly what Starshadow needed to hear. Her back arched and she bit her hoof to keep from crying out loud enough to wake everypony in Ponyville as she finally came. Applejack unfortunately found herself standing in a somewhat impractical spot as Starshadow's pussy began to squirt and the first wave of her cum hit AJ directly in her face. Caught off guard by Starshadow's ejaculate, Applejack stumbled backwards and fell down on her plot and was unable to get herself out of the way of the second and third quick spurts. Luckily for her Starshadow's orgasm didn't last long, but the exhausted pegasus mare was in no shape to move and quickly lost consciousness once she started to come down.

Applejack wiped her face off but was unable to stop a small trickle of Starshadow's fluids from slipping into the corner of her mouth. Her first instinct was to spit out the other mare's fluids, but just as she was about to she found that the taste wasn't as bad as she had thought. Her tongue slipped out of her mouth to retrieve more of the stuff on her face and she quickly eyed the unconscious mare. Thoughts of lapping up the fluid still present on her crotch teased Applejack's mind, but before she could decide whether to take action or not Big Mac returned. "Big Mac!" Applejack called out to him

The red stallion was desperately out of breath, having chased Thunderlane as far as he could before the cowardly pegasus flew upwards and disappeared into the clouds. "Lost him... too fast... flew up..." he panted.

"Don' worry none about that, I'll get Rainbow Dash ter help track that scumbag down." Applejack said. "But first we need ter get her back ter the farm."

Before Applejack could attempt to hoist the unconscious pegasus onto her back, Big Mac stepped forward and put Starshadow on his back. "What'n the hay are ya doin?" Applejack asked him. "Let me carry her, ya'll just finished runnin' clear across town, and if I know ya at all, ya'll probably tried flyin after him."

Big Mac shook his head. "I got this." he said, ignoring the fact that his sister was right. He was absolutely exhausted, and he would never admit that he had indeed tried jumping into the air to catch Thunderlane. Starshadow's small body felt like he was now carrying an entire train on his back, but he shoved the pain out of his mind and made the careful walk back to the farm with Applejack in tow.

By the time the three ponies made it back to the farm hints of sunlight were just appearing on the horizon. Applejack held the doors open while Big Mac wearily made his way upstairs and gently deposited Starshadow down on AJ's bed. Once he had tucked her in and kissed her on the head his legs gave out and he crumbled onto the floor. Having guessed that this would happen sooner than later, Applejack had a glass of water ready for her brother and gave it to him, watching as he emptied the large glass in a matter of seconds. He shakily stood back up but Applejack stopped him from exiting. "Woah there, partner, ya'll ain't going nowhere." she said to him. "Don' worry about the chores, ah can finish them up mahself."

Big Mac nodded in thanks but found himself stopped by his sister once again as he tried to go to his room. Applejack turned slightly red and averted her gaze as she spoke. "There ain't no way ya'll can even make it back ter yer room. 'Sides, she shouldn't be alone after what happened ter her." she said. "J-just no funny business in my bed withou... no funny business!" Having almost said 'without me' at the end, she quickly ran off to go find Rainbow Dash to help her track down Thunderlane.

Big Mac didn't have the energy to wonder why Applejack was acting a little strange just now and barely managed to climb into her bed and cuddle up next to Starshadow. He felt a knot in his stomach as he recalled the words coming out of Starshadow's mouth as he and Applejack came up on her and Thunderlane, and soon those thoughts were joined up by her past odd behavior; calling him Master, wanting him to always be forceful and rough with her...

Big Mac took a deep breath and cleared his mind. There was no use worrying about that right now, but when he and Starshadow awoke he would ask her all about that and try to fit the pieces of her past together.