FSE

Furry search engine

formerly SoFurry search engine

The Bunny Switch

Part two of three

---

Written by Arian Mabe (Amethyst Mare)

Commissioned by Ninnin

_ _

_ _

Jack trotted up, his big, pink member bouncing about all over the place: another stallion. Yet he was more finely built than the palomino, Axel, and dripping in golden-brown hair instead: a bright, glowing bay horse.

“Uh, she okay?" He asked, tilting Maddie's head up and checking that she wasn't choking. “Damn, she's out cold. Do we need to call her husband?"

“Nah, I think there was a mix-up with the Tylenol – she got one of ours instead," Axel said, his nostrils fluttering in sympathy. “She talked about getting knocked out accidentally before though, like being so into it she passed out from getting off. We can keep going, as long as everything's alright with her. That's right, isn't it, Vaughn?"

Of course, they had to check first and the bull nodded, though he was most certainly going to keep a close eye on her.

“Yeah, that's fine," he said. “I'll text Ninnin though, just in case there's something we don't know."

Everything was fine, however, even if they were very much in the right to be careful about things. The horses lined up with her on her back, though Maddie could not exactly wrap her legs around the partner sliding between them when she was unconscious. Yet the bunny would find it all incredibly erotic to watch back later, as some of the other guys recorded her on phones and handheld cameras, as Axel slid into her mouth.

The thickness of his bulge obviously showed through her neck as he ground deep, holding on to either side of her head as he worked his cock back and forth. The stallion, on his knees, grunted and lashed his tail, losing himself in the moment as he used the limp, floppy bunny for all he was worth.

“Heh, Jess…" Axel grunted, his white tail raising beautifully. “You always were the queen in the LARP scene, huh? Mmm, but you're so hot… Just a cum dump now…"

The words were not meant in mean spirits, yet the guys slipped into the fantasy of having the real rabbit from the LARP group to fuck – as was their right. Maddie made a more than adequate substitute and Jack groaned as he pushed between her legs, both her pussy and her ass drooling cum already. Yet he chose the sloppier, wetter mess of her pussy to grind into, his shaft burrowing into her slick heat with a moan of delight.

“Ah… Yes… Bunny…"

Jack couldn't get out all the words he wanted in the moment, though it didn't really matter. His gaze grazed Axel's and the stallions laughed softly at one another, a rippling nicker wound through their lust for the bunny between them.

Others moved around them, muttering about getting her bred, but there was no one there to stop them from not using condoms on Maddie either. The bunny had already been too out of it with her headache before trying to find some medicine, though it was a wonder, really, that she had not seen the soaking deluge of bull cum marking her inner thighs from the burst condom.

That would just be a delightful little surprise for her to find out later.

“Dude… We're really going to knock her up this time," Jack groaned, the stallion's grey nostrils quivering as he slammed into her, embracing the welcoming, tight pull of her pussy. “Mmmph… Fuck… She's going to have a womb full of colts."

“Better fuck her harder then," Axel advised, the bulge of his cock dragging back and forth through Maddie's wonderfully abused throat. “Or else one of the dogs will get her."

Jack groaned.

“Or the zebra, or the buffalo… Heck, is Vincent here today too? Damn it."

Axel laughed, his balls tightening and tail flagging, the stallion on the brink of orgasm.

“Yeah, we got our work cut out of us. So, let's fill up this condom!"

“Hah – yeah! We don't need a condom if she is the bunny condom!"

Of course, the palomino stallion was referring to Maddie in that moment, but the studs slammed in together, both revelling in the tightness of her body around them in different manners. Yet their orgasms were what the horses could both revel in as they erupted at nearly the same moment.

A hot wash of cum poured straight down Maddie's throat. Although Axel pulled back once his climax was done, he stayed deep in that moment, so he could pour every last drop of his cum straight down her throat, without risking her actually choking on it. Maddie might not have had a gag reflex after taking her first cock of the night down her throat, but he wanted to be considerate of her all the same.

Even if Axel saw the similar bunny, Jessie, under him, not Maddie. He saw her cheeks bulging with his cock and felt her tongue sliding around his cock, even if she was not conscious to be able to do anything about it in that moment. And it was the hottest thing the stallion had ever seen in his life, to imagine that he was creaming down the real Jessie's throat and watching that perhaps “not so slutty" bunny getting what he wanted to give her for a long time.

It was nobody's fault, of course, that Jessie wasn't into that kind of thing. But they'd all learned how to roleplay in different ways in the LARP group, so it had only been a natural progression to find a way to make their fantasies a reality. All while being respectful of Jessie, of course.

Jack grunted powerfully as he crammed every last inch of his cock into “Jessie," burying it deep so he could rub the outline of his massive member through her lower abdomen. He moaned, losing control, as pump after pump of thick semen flooded her pussy. It forced its way up into Maddie's womb from the sheer force of it – and, after all it had to have somewhere to go too. Some of his seed squelched and drooled back out around the tight fit of his cock inside her, straining her pussy seemingly to its limits.

Yet the bunny could take every inch from multiple cocks at once: one horse was not going to stress her body all that much. It was up to Jack, however, to feed into his own fantasy as he lingered in the moment, his chest heaving as dark patches of sweat showed through his coat, lips parted even though he was breathing sharply through his nostrils.

After that, the guys clamoured for Maddie's attention, although every one of them made sure to mark off a tally on her rump, covering her with black marks, to show just how many cocks she'd taken. Without Cody being actively there filming that time, the video would have to be a little shakier and more intimate still, although there were some cameras set up throughout multiple rooms from higher vantage points too. Of course, the stallion would be paid well, as ever, for recording the session and doing the work of editing the best parts together for Ninnin and Maddie to enjoy later.

A dog, Archer, with a thick, fluffy tail, though he was definitely a hybrid of two different types of canines in how he presented himself physically, laughed as he drew on her belly. Big, pink arrows from the fur-safe marker pointed to her pussy, though the others playfully grabbed at one another for more markers to join him.

So, even as the bunny posing as Jessie was fucked, the writing grew on her body, sprawling over her form to cover even around her breasts and up the length of her back.

Cum slut here!

_ _

Fill her up!

_ _

Knocked up

_ _

Big dickz only

_ _

Queen bunny slut

_ _

Bunny whore Jess

_ _

Cum in me

_ _

And the tally marks – oh, so many tally marks as the guys hastened to use her, sometimes the dogs taking her with their thick, plump knots and sometimes the stallions working their flares deep. She was carried around the party as her pussy, ass and throat were all used equally. Two dogs, a pair of huskies, double-penetrated her pussy just to see if she could get both their knots into her that time, grunting and whining as they pressed close.

“Agh…" One said, his knot engorged and grinding far too kinkily against that of his friend's in the moment. “Jess… She's so tight!"

“Well, she's got two dicks stuffed in her! What do you expect?"

The dogs laughed, though they, perhaps, should have thought about how they were going to knot Maddie before they had let their knots grow as fat as they had. There was nothing to be done about it, however, as they stood together and pinned her between their bodies, one hoisting up her leg so he could cram into her more powerfully from the front.

“Unff… Ah… Jess!"

The dogs howled, broken words woven through as they cried out about knocking up “Jess," though it seemed everyone there was deep in the fantasy of the bunny there actually being the one they coveted so much. To breed was something special indeed and the huskies bodily shuddered together as Maddie's pussy clung to them in the tightest of velvety sleeves. Hardly any cum or her arousal escaped her pussy that time, not with the tight grasp of her cunny wrapped around two cocks and knots at once.

There was only so much a bunny could stretch, after all, and she'd need a third cock to really pry her open even more than that. Liquid, however, viscous, simply was not a problem in that instance of her body to trap inside her, lusciously ready to spill over the moment the pressure plugs of their cocks were released.

Harvey and Ambrose spirited Maddie away to one of the bedrooms to use her between them, though the grey stallion with dapples on his rump was a little on the greedy side. It could not be denied and Harvey would never have turned away from his true nature either, as he warmed up on the bed by dragging Maddie's head up and down his cock.

“Mmm, this is just a warmup, Jessie," he moaned, relishing in the spittle drooling from her mouth, lips soft on his mottled pink and grey cock. “I can't wait to be buried in your tight pussy… See you get knocked up and swell with my foal."

“Or maybe a buffalo calf," Ambrose shot back, though the big, burly buffalo was positioned between her legs already. “I'm going first here, I've got the better chance."

As the buffalo pushed into Maddie's soaked pussy, he had to keep her hips hitched up – or else the unconscious bunny would have just tipped off to the side, slumped on the bed. Unfortunately for her, there was only one camera in that room, although it would still show a nice shot afterwards.

Of the buffalo's cock pushing into her as he thrust, grinding back and forth, her folds pulling out ever so slightly around his thick meat as if she was trying to keep him inside her even in that moment. With her head bouncing into Ambrose's lap, she looked like she was actively engaged in giving him head, her ears flopping about all over the place.

Yet it was not to be that easy, oh no, not at all. The horse and the buffalo made use of her body as they pushed into her and Harvey took a marker, adding a heart over each nipple, though he had to awkwardly reach around and under her body to do so. It didn't matter if his artistry wasn't that neat, however, as he sank his cock deep and Ambrose humped her face furiously, crushing her nose lightly into his crotch with every thrust.

Others, however, were looking for Maddie, as Jessie, too and hunted for her throughout the house. Whereas some came upon her with Harvey and Ambrose, others were misled and headed up to the upper level of the house, looking for their cum dump bunny toy for the night.

“Unff, I haven't even got my cock wet yet," a Bernese Mountain dog complained with a good-natured roll of his eyes, his tail still wagging eagerly. “The knots really have to get her bred good this time!"

Another dog, a Golden Retriever, cocked his head, though his hard prick ruined the otherwise cute moment.

“Aren't we meant to be wearing condoms?" He asked thoughtfully, though it was not something he was going to push. “Didn't she usually ask for that?"

“Yeah," the Bernese Mountain dog said with a roll of his shoulders. “But it's okay, I checked. She only said Vaughn had to wear one, so we're all free and clear to see if we get her knocked up this time!"

There was always something of a competition, after all, between the knots and flares to see who could breed Maddie the most, although they were seeing her as another. There were other anthros there that night too who didn't have knots and flares, like the buffalo and the goat to say the least, so it was kind of a moot point when it came to the friendly rivalry even within the LARP group.

“Come on, Jessie's got to be around her somewhere," another dog muttered, though his tail wagged so fervently that it brushed against his friends as he moved. “What're we all waiting for?"

“Yeah, got to get her bred, oh heck… Can't wait to spread those sexy legs of hers and see how much cum has been pumped into the brat already!"

“Oof!"

Vincent grunted, the goat trying to shift away – but it was too late as he collided with the dogs. The goat anthro hadn't been looking where he was going and his horns knocked into the wall as he scrambled. Yet it was too late to stop a drink going straight down his front as the Golden Retriever's hand slipped, a slosh of alcohol pouring down his front.

“Ah, shoot – I'm sorry!"

The Golden Retriever canine fussed and tried to help him out, although there was not all that much he could do in a moment like that, no. The goat's shirt was soaked through and the booze was already dripping into his fur, though Vincent tried to laugh it off.

“Oh, hey, it's okay, no harm really!"

Vincent, however, was cursing inwardly at the fact that he wasn't going to get to find “Jessie" all that quickly. How could he get a drink spilled all over him when everything going on there was just fun? But little things like that were not to set him back, no, even if he couldn't head into the closest bathroom as one of the other dogs was turning the corner right into there.

That forced Vincent to go upstairs to the topmost floor of the three-storey building, which included the ground floor, to find the last bathroom. He tried to hold his shirt out away from his chest so the booze would not get into his chest too much, but there was only so much he could do then.

It meant he had to duck his way through a bedroom with the lights off, the smell of booze in his nostrils so the goat didn't notice the bunny sitting on the bed at that time. It was not Maddie, however, but the real Jessie, who had received a very interesting message only a couple of hours earlier.

Yet she didn't quite know why she was there, wearing a comfortable skirt and shoes that still showed off her body nicely. Her top was cropped to expose her belly, though it was all very much in her style.

It was weird, that house she'd got the address of: all the guys walking around naked and her slipping through the throng, lingering on the edges without, of course, getting involved. Some seemed to be enjoying a gangbang, if that was even the right term to use, and she just didn't get why she was there when she only was into girls.

Maybe Vaughn forgot, or had something to show me for next week's session? She thought, though even that seemed a very flimsy excuse to her. Sheesh, don't these guys think about anything other than sex?

_ _

If Maddie had not been in a room upstairs, however, Jessie might have seen her and realised exactly what was going on. Seeing only naked guys hanging about was more confusing than anything else, though it was not quite something the bunny wanted to know.

The goat, not knowing she was in the bedroom while he used the en-suite bathroom, had his shirt off to wash it, running it under the cold water tap and wrinkling his nose. It would not get the smell out, he was sure, though Vincent didn't know what else to do, honestly. He had to try, though he doubted there would exactly be piles of clothes lying around there for him to even try on to see if something would fit him.

If I don't hurry up, I'm going to miss out on everything, the goat lamented, even if the rabbit would be there all night, he was sure really. Sheesh… Do I even need a shirt? But this one was pricey!

_ _

He wanted to save it, though not that badly, perhaps. The door to the bathroom swung open, spilling light into the darkened bedroom, and he stiffened. Was someone in there? He was sure that was someone with grey fur he could see on the bed, the rustle of clothing catching his attention.

Jess inhaled deeply, crossing her legs. It was kind of a turn on, perhaps, to see all that sex going on around her, though it was not hot in the slightest to have all those dicks just being slung around. It could not be alluring to her, but it was intriguing. And perhaps that was just what kept Jess hanging around when she really should have moved on and checked out what was going on there.

She parted her legs a little and rubbed over her pussy, though she was conscious of the goat who had stalked through to the bathroom as if his tail was on fire. That was strange enough on its own but he didn't seem to be threatening in any way. Not that Jess didn't think, in any way, that she couldn't look after herself, of course.

Vincent, however, didn't know that Jess was not Maddie, the bunny they'd arranged to all fuck in every possible way that night. He grunted and hung up his shirt to dry and, hopefully, not reek of alcohol next time he came back for it, but he was keener than ever to get back out there and find the bunny.

Yet he was in luck! The anthro he found in the bedroom was none other than “Maddie" herself!

“Hey, I didn't know you were in here, Jess!" He said, greeting her cheerily in character, even though he really “knew" the bunny was Maddie. “I didn't think I'd get to see you all by myself!"

Jess cocked her head, her ears flopping to the side as her brow furrowed.

“Uh, yeah, thanks, Vincent?" She said, though confusion laced her tone as her nose twitched. “I don't really know why I'm here, Vaughn texted me to come down here."

Vincent grinned. Finally, he caught a lucky break!

“Oh, I know why you're here," he said, stepping up to the bunny as he loosened his belt, wishing he had already got all of his clothes off. “Don't worry, I'll give you the ride of your life, bunny."

“Uh…"

Jess leaned back, her eyes wide. What the heck was Vincent doing? Was he really getting his cock out? What the hell!

“Don't worry, I'm more than happy to give you the chance with a guy, Jess," he said confidently, although there was no aggression in his tone. “There's no reason, after all, why you should go without getting to try it out for yourself. Am I going to be your first dick tonight? Wow, that's kind of cool…"

“I'm not really a penis person, you know that already, Vincent…"

The goat grinned and nodded.

“Yeah, I know, that's why I'm glad to help you out with this. I know the other guys will too, if you haven't had them already."

“Uh…"

Jess grunted, leaning back, though not knowing what else to do. It was strange to go along with it as Vincent, from the LARP group, took her hand and put it on his crotch. His jeans slid down as his cock throbbed against her hand, though Jess didn't pull away. What was she supposed to do with something like that? Her lips pressed together and she grimaced lightly, but didn't push him away as perhaps she should have.

“Vincent, I don't really think I'm into this…"

“Heh, you're so into the role, Jess, I love it!"

The goat seemed genuinely enthused by all that was going on and, without really thinking about it, Jess worked her hand up and down the hard length of his cock. How it throbbed into her hand was strange, so different to fingering a pussy, though she didn't really feel like she wanted to let it go either.

She'd never had a cock in her hand before and the bunny folded her soft fingers, her hands devoid of paw pads like the dogs, around his cock. Her fingers would not close all the way around it and, as if she wasn't at all aware of the goat his cock was attached to, she worked her hand up and down, squeezing around the base lightly.

“Hm… This is weird…"

“Yeah, Jess, mmm…" He groaned, putting his hand on her shoulder to guide the bunny down from the bed on to her knees. “Just like that… It's really like you've not had a cock before."

“Uh, well, I haven't?"

Jess rolled her eyes at him and was about to say something a lot sharper to the goat. Yet it was not as if Vincent had done anything aggressive or even really forced her at all, it was just that she hadn't known what was going on. With her nose level with his cock, she wrinkled up her snout and turned her head away again.

Yeah… That cock she didn't like being up close and personal with, though her face turned back to his dick, staring at the head. She didn't want it, no, but her interest was there, confusion all bundled up in the pit of her stomach.

But that didn't mean she was going to suck his cock, oh no. Not even as the goat's fingers curled around the back of her neck and guided Jess' lips to his cock.

“Mmmph?"

She groaned, though it was too late. Jess' lips parted at just the wrong moment as Vincent parted her lips with his cock. The goat moaned aloud and thrust deeper, making sure she could not easily get his cock out of her mouth, needing it desperately.

“Oof… Oh, yeah… Can't believe I'm really…mmm…your first dick…"

Jess moaned around him, her hands coming up, although she didn't really push him away. It was just such a big change in sensation that she was busy grappling with, her lips pushing tightly around his cock as she sort of sucked on him.

The goat, of course, still thought that Jess was Maddie, even if it would have been Maddie roleplaying as Jess. He was too busy revelling in the moment as he ground his cock deep, admiring just how deeply she committed to the role as the bunny from the LARP group. He had not even thought Maddie and Jessie knew one another all that well, but Maddie played Jess perfectly!

The bunny was not very active in sucking his cock, though her tongue flicked anxiously up against the underside and Vincent allowed himself to be caught by the moment just a little more. He thrust, holding on to her ears, though he didn't feel her trying to shudder back and away from him. It was only a meagre, faint attempt to get him away from her, though it was so slight that the goat didn't even notice.

He just wanted more of her mouth as he leaned into his roleplay, truly imagining he was fucking Jess' mouth. Vincent would never have forced her, of course, but he wanted his moment too, allowing the fantasy to play out even more deliciously than it had in the sanctity of his own mind. He groaned as he rolled his hips, thrusting and sliding into the back of her throat.

“Mmmph!"

Jess shoved against his thighs, her eyes streaming as her gag reflex rebelled. Thankfully, nothing bad happened with her stomach lurching as it was, though she drooled around his cock as she pulled back. She tried to control her gag reflex, though her vision blurred as she tried to blink away the moisture.

Vincent, however, didn't seem to notice her concern over what was happening, though he did pause briefly to stroke her ears and run his hands back over them. That felt nicer, though it was nothing at all like the touch of a femfur.

She tried to explore it a little. It was difficult to get into it, though it was Jess' interest in what was going on that had her nose twitching and her muzzle wrinkling with distaste at the same time. A cock tasted so different too: all smooth and almost a little musky. She was glad, however, that the goat seemed like he had washed recently, so he was fresh and clean in that regard.

“Mmm, oh, Jess… I can't wait to push into your hole for the first time," Vincent moaned, though the goat was not honestly sure whether the bunny had been with guys or not before. “Going to give you a full litter of bunnies in your womb too… Not gonna wear a condom. I know the games you play, telling only one guy to wear a condom. Mm, you're such a tease!"

Vincent slipped in and out of his role, partly referring to Jess and partly to Maddie, though it was fair enough that the bunnies blended together in his head. However, the goat wanted more as she struggled playfully, as enchanted as he was by how she acted like it wasn't something she had signed up for. It was all so alluring, as if she was pulling out every last little trick to please him and play into her role.

Vincent couldn't hold back for a single moment more.

He grunted as he withdrew from her mouth and pushed over her at the same time. Her crop top rode up a little – but the goat was interested in her skirt and nothing else. Pinning her down to the floor, he used his weight against her and pulled her short skirt up to show off her panties, although the bunny, surprisingly so, didn't resist.

“Mm, you really want this…"

Vincent laughed a little to himself, thinking that Maddie was slipping out of the role. Yet the goat held her lustfully down in a mating press, holding her thighs apart with his as his hard prick prodded at her pussy. Vincent just about got her underwear tugged to the side, for there didn't seem enough time in the slightest to get it off her.

Not as he pushed into her, the bunny lying there prone as his cock drove deeper and deeper into her.

Jess, on the other hand, didn't know what to do, not in the slightest, her lips parted faintly. Her ears stood up to attention, although she simply didn't know how to react as his cock bore its way up deep inside her. It was nothing like a dildo but so very warm and she squeaked as he stretched her out, quivering in place without actually being held in place. Her hands and arms, of course, were left free, so she could have done something to stop things at any time.

Only, Jess didn't know how on earth she was meant to do that as he drove into her, finding a rhythm and pace that suited him for his thrusts. Jess even let out a breathy moan, her body trembling with desire under him.

“Ah…"

“That's right, going to give you every inch, bunny-bun."

“Mmph – ah!"

She groaned, still frozen, though trapped by the pleasure of her own body. It was good, in a way, though it was like nothing she'd ever had before as she rested there. She didn't protest, not even as her fingers twitched as if they wanted to do something, though Jess was not truly present in her own mind as she simply allowed the goat to do exactly as he wanted to her.

Vincent huffed and grunted, though didn't mind her quiet. It was all part of the play, after all, and, if he was honest, the goat wasn't all that interested in anyone struggling or pushing back against him, no. He wanted someone who was into it and wanted them to feel good. But he wanted Jess too, even if it was Maddie playing the part of Jess. And rather well too…

He grunted and huffed as he powered into her, his balls aching as he tried to hold back from orgasm. Vincent licked his lips and let his back end do all the work, though his glutes were already getting rather sore. She was so beautiful, even in the half-light under him, artificial light spilling out from the bathroom where he had left the door open.

Hell, she even looked like Jess, even more so, just like that. He pumped in deeply with a long, low groan, quivering on the edge.

“Ah, Jess, going to cum inside," he moaned. “It'd be so hot to knock you up, see your belly grow so big with my kids…"

Jess wriggled at that, her eyes wide. No! No, she couldn't have kids! Not even any kids, let alone goat kids! She pushed at him weakly, coming a little more back to her senses, as she implored him.

“No… No, Vincent," Jess murmured, knowing who the goat was as her ears folded back. “I don't want to get pregnant… Please, please, don't cum inside!"

There was a hard, urgent bite to her tone – and thankfully the goat listened to it. Pulling out, he surveyed her for a moment as if he wasn't sure what or who he was looking at.

It wasn't enough for Vincent to stop, however, even though “Maddie's" acting truly was excellent. She really looked like Jess, but he had to keep going. He knelt over her head the moment after he'd pulled out and jacked off vigorously. Yet it took Vincent only a few, hard strokes of his cock to erupt all over her face.

He may have lost himself in the moment of long shots of creamy cum splattering her face, clinging to the ridge of her nose and drooling down, but Jess was right there, feeling everything. She panted heavily, lips only slightly parted, a drool of cum lingering on her lips. As if she wasn't really thinking about what she was doing, she lapped it off in a quick dark and flick of her tongue.

The bunny moaned and Vincent laughed breathlessly, giddy in the aftermath of orgasm. Seed trickled over her face and, wanting to capture the moment, he grabbed his phone from his discarded clothes, snapping a picture.

“Damn, you look so hot," he murmured, lost in the moment. “All that cum on your face, damn…"

“Yeah, she really does!"

Jess blinked and looked up, still frozen in the moment, as a horde of guys spilled into the bedroom. It was as if they had simply been waiting for Vincent to finish, though it was most likely simply excellent timing on their part.

Jess didn't feel the same way, by any means, trying to scramble back as the guys flooded in, all wanting to go right back to playing with their toy. They just thought the goat had snuck her away for a little private fun, when Maddie was supposed to be servicing the entire party – as agreed, of course. How greedy of him!

Continued in part three of three…