Mistress Shy

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter One

#1 of mistress shy's new pet arctic is a stallion with sizeable assets but a certain mare catches his eye when her skirt flips up at just the wrong moment.

Amethyst Mare, Arian Mabe, Bondage, Commission, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Dress, Equestria, Equine, Femdom, Feral, First Chapter, Fluttershy, Horse, Hyper, Hyperphallic, Large Cock, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, Mistress shy's new pet, My Little Pony, NC, Non-Anthro, Non-Consensual, Orders, Peeping, Pet, Pony, Pony Play, Power, Rule 34, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Submissive, Teasing, Trickery, Upskirt, bridle, clothing, control, dominant, drug use, instruction, mistress, ponyville, tea

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Two

"please, mistress shy, please let me cum." the words rushed from his muzzle, tumbling over one another in their haste to be released. "i'll do anything for you, please just let me cum, mistress shy, please, oh please, oh please!"

Abuse, Anal, Anal Sex, Anal play, Anal toys, Ball inflation, Basement, Bondage, Chaining, Chains, Commission, Cum Inflation, Domination, Domination/Submission, Dominatrix, Domshy, Dungeon, Equestria, Equine, Erotic, Femdom, Feral, Feral pony, Fluttershy, Gag, Gagging, Groping, Handjob, Horse, Humiliation, Hyper, Hyper balls, Hyperphallic, Inflation, Large Cock, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, My Little Pony, NC, Non-Anthro, Non-Consensual, Orgasm Control, Orgasm Denial, Pet, Pet Play, Pony, Predicament Bondage, Rape, Sex toys, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Submission, Teasing, Vibrator, begging, bridle, erotica, hoofjob, large balls, mistress, ponyville

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Six

#6 of mistress shy's new pet arctic is abused further in fluttershy's dungeon as she breaks him into her obedient pet... --- one more! looks like there's only chapter seven and the small epilogue to go!

Abuse, Amethyst Mare, Anal, Anal Sex, Arian Mabe, BDSM, Ball inflation, Basement, Blowjob, Bondage, Cage, Caging, Commission, Cowgirl, Cum Inflation, Cunnilingus, Dildo, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Dungeon, Egg, Equine, Erotic, Femdom, Feral, Fluttershy, Forced Orgasm, Gag, Groping, Heavy bondage, Horse, Hyper, Hyperphallic, Inflation, Large Cock, Licking, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, My Little Pony, Non-Anthro, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Pain, Pet, Pet Play, Pony, Riding, Sex dungeon, Sex toy insertion, Sex toys, Size Difference, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Teasing, Urethra insertion, Vaginal, Vaginal Sex, Vibrator, erotica, mistress, ring gag, sucking, urethra play

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Five

#5 of mistress shy's new pet arctic wakes, bound and at the mercy of a certain pegasus intent on pleasuring and torturing him further. and yet, she's not alone again... --- long day. rubbish with vets and over-dramatic horses.

Amethyst Mare, Anal, Anal Sex, Arian Mabe, BDSM, Bondage, Cage, Caging, Commission, Cum Inflation, Cunnilingus, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Equestria, Equine, Erotic, Female led, Femdom, Feral, Fluttershy, Heavy bondage, Hyper, Hyper balls, Hyperphallic, Inflation, Lactation, Licking, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, Mental play, Milking, Multiple partners, My Little Pony, Nipples, Non-Anthro, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Pegasus, Pet, Pet Play, Pony, Pregnancy, Pregnant, Rough Sex, Semi-NC, Sex toys, Spitfire, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Submissive, Threesome, colt, dominant, erotica, mistress, ponyville, pump, pumping, sucking, teats, udders

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Seven

#7 of mistress shy's new pet it all comes to a head as arctic must prove that he's worthy of mistress shy's loving dominance... --- and...we have the final "chapter"!

Abuse, Amethyst Mare, Anal, Anal Sex, Arian Mabe, Blowjob, Bondage, Cock pump, Collar, Collaring, Cunnilingus, Deep Penetration, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Equine, Exhibitionism, Femdom, Feral, Fluttershy, Gangbang, Group, Group Sex, Heavy bondage, Horse, Hyper, Hyperphallic, Impact play, Inflation, Lactation, Large Cock, Latex, M/F, MLP, Magic, Mare, Marebang, Master/Pet, Milking, My Little Pony, Non-Anthro, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Pain play, Pet, Pet Play, Potion, Pregnancy, Public, Reverse gangbang, Semi-NC, Sex toys, Size Difference, Stallion, Submissive, Teasing, Vaginal, Vaginal Sex, Vanilla Sex, Voyeurism, Watersports, Whipping, colt, exhibitionist, flogger, mistress, pomy, pump, sucking, voyeur, whip

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Four

#4 of mistress shy's new pet mistress shy has more in mind still for poor arctic but the stallion's worst humiliation is yet to come... --- next up!

Anal, Anal Sex, BDSM, Bondage, Cage, Caging, Chains, Commission, Cunnilingus, Dominant mares, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Equestria, Equine, Erotic, Exhibitionism, Femdom, Feral, Fluttershy, Group Sex, Heavy bondage, Horse, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, Multiple partners, My Little Pony, NC, Non-Anthro, Non-Consensual, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Pet, Pet Play, Pony, Rough Sex, Scent, Sex toys, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Threesome, Urine, Vaginal, Vaginal Sex, Voyeurism, Watersports, Whipping, colt, erotica, exhibitionist, marking, mistress, ponyville, public sex, voyeur

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Three

#3 of mistress shy's new pet arctic wakes, bound and inflated for mistress shy's pleasure... --- a pleasure to upload again and move this story forward! poor arctic... she's really being oh so very delightfully wicked, isn't she?

Anal, Anal Sex, Bondage, CBT, Cock Milking, Cock pump, Colt pony, Commission, Cowgirl, Cum Inflation, Cunnilingus, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Equestria, Equine, Femdom, Feral, Fluttershy, Groping, Heavy bondage, Horse, Humiliation, Hyper, Hyper balls, Hyperphallic, Inflation, Licking, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, Milking, My Little Pony, NC, Non-Anthro, Non-Consensual, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Original Character, Pain, Pain play, Pet, Pet Play, Riding, Rimming, Sex toys, Size diference, Stallion, Story, Story Series, Teasing, Vaginal, Vaginal Sex, begging, bridle, mistress, ponyville, pump, sucking

Mistress Shy's New Pet: Chapter Eight

"i'm ready to come home, mistress shy." and home he was.

Amethyst Mare, Arian Mabe, Collar, Collaring, Cutie Mark, Domination/Submission, Domshy, Equine, Femdom, Feral, Horse, Love, M/F, MLP, Mare, Master/Pet, Mistress shy's new pet, My Little Pony, Non-Anthro, OC, Pet, Pony, Semi-NC, Shy, Stallion, Submissive, Unconventional relationships, broken, colt, epilogue, mistress, no sex

Bound in the Stalls: Part One

The old scar in there still made it difficult to take things up there, even though mistress shy had stretched him out time after time again and, after a while, any discomfort did fade completely to pleasure.

Amethyst Mare, Anal, Anal penetration, Anthro, BDSM, Big Cock, Bondage, Cock tube, Commission, Domination, Domination/Submission, Equine, Exhibitionism, Female dominant, Femdom, Feral, First Chapter, Fluttershy, Full encasement, Gag, Group, Group Sex, Heavy bondage, Heavy fetish, Horse, Horse Cock, Hyper, Hyper Cock, Hyper balls, Hyperphallic, Kinky, Latex, MLP, Mare, Mini story series, My Little Pony, Non-Anthro, OC, Original Character, Pony, Public, Rough, Rough Sex, Stallion, Story Series, Submission, Submissive, Voyeurism, arctic, bar, dominant, exhibitionist, fetish, kink, latex suit, public sex, sounding, urethral penetration, voyeur

Punished for Her Pleasure: Part Five

mistress shy was there. well, there had to have been something to wake him up.

Abuse, Anal, Anal Sex, BDSM, Bareback, Deep Penetration, Dildo, Domination, Domination/Submission, Dubcon, Dubious consent, Equine, Erotic, Fart, Female, Femdom, Filth, Fluttershy, Forced, Horse, Hyper, Hyper Cock, Hyper Inflation, Hyper balls, Inflation, Kinky, Living toilet, M/F, MLP, Male, Male/Female, Mare, Mistress shy, Mistress/slave, My litlte pony, Non-Anthro, Noxious gas, Oral, Oral Sex, Pet, Piss, Pony, Punishment, Rough, Rough Sex, Scat, Semi non-consensual, Semi-NC, Sex toys, Short Story, Size Difference, Size Play, Slave, Stallion, Story, Straight, Straight Sex, Submission, Submissive, Toilet, Toilet slut, Torture, Urine, Water Sports, Watersports, Wet, Wet play, arctic, bodily fluids, dominant, erotica, fetish, force, gas, kink, mistress, pee, resistance, waste

Accidental Inflation

mistress shy was going to punish him something dreadful!

Accidental, Air, Belly Inflation, Commission, Dubcon, Dubious consent, Equine, Erotic, Exhibitionism, Farm, Feral, Fluttershy, Horse, Hosing, Huge stomach, Hyper, Hyper Cock, Hyper Inflation, Hyper balls, Hyper belly, Hyperphallic, Inflation, M/solo, MLP, Male/solo, Milk, Mistress shy, My Little Pony, Non-Anthro, Original Character, Pegasus, Piping, Pony, Risk, Risky sex, Room inflation, Rough, Short Story, Size Play, Size growth, Solo, Stallion, Story, Teasing, erotica, hose, huge balls, huge belly, huge cock, mistake, mistress, pipe, playful, predicament, swelling

Punished for Her Pleasure: Part One

#20 of mistress shy's new pet mistress shy decides to see how far she can push her pony-pet, filling him with aphrodisiacs and flaunting her assets to him so that he simply can't escape her feminine charm...

Anal, Anal Sex, Arousal, BDSM, Backed up cum, Ball inflation, Bareback, Cage, Caging, Chastity, Consensual relationship, Cunnilingus, Deep Penetration, Domination, Domination/Submission, Dubcon, Equine, Erotic, Exhibitionism, Extreme, Extreme arousal, Extreme teasing, Female, Female dominant, Female domination, Femdom, Fluttershy, Forced, Horse, Humiliation, Hyper, Hyper Cock, Hyper balls, Hyperphallic, Inflation, M/F, MLP, Male, Male/Female, Mare, Mistress shy, Mistress/Pet, My Little Pony, OC, Oral, Oral Sex, Orgasm Control, Orgasm Denial, Original Character, Pegasus, Pet, Pony, Public, Punishment, Reverse orgasm, Semi non-consensual, Semi-NC, Short Story, Size Difference, Stallion, Story, Straight, Straight Sex, Submission, Submissive, Teasing, Vaginal, Vaginal Sex, arctic, denial, dominant, erotica, exhibitionist, flirting, force, hyper cum, mistress, public sex