Given what little she knew about his history with transformation potions, there was a good chance his asshole produced the same sorts of natural lubricants that his pussy did when he was female, a residual effect of constant gender swapping.
Anal, Anal Fisting, Anatomically Correct, Anthro, Anthro/feral, Anthropomorphic, Avian, Barbs, Bestiality, Bulge, Creampie, Cumshot, Cunnilingus, Equine, Farm, Feathers, Feline, Female, Feral, Fisting, Flare, Gryphon, Hybrid, Licking, M/F, Magic, Male, Oral, Outdoors, Party, Potion, Quadruped, Rimming, Size Difference, Sizeplay Size Play, Stallion, Straight, Tiger, Transformation, Vaginal, Zoophilia, barn, belly bulge, bellybulge, biped, caught, closeup, cutaway, flared, outside, pirates, ranch, sloppy seconds, suck, sucking